Sheaffer Told Me To

fashion influencer blog

Black Jeans? Really? YES MA’AM!

By 84 Comments

 I used to have a pair of black jeans.
I say used to because I donated them a couple of years ago.
Why did I donate them?
Because I never wore them.
Never.
Ever.I would put them on, but then I would always take them off before leaving the house.
I just thought that maybe black jeans weren’t for me.

But then last year I started seeing DARLING outfits all over Pinterest….outfits with black jeans.
Outfits that I couldn’t recreate because I didn’t have a pair of black jeans.
#bloggerfail

This year I couldn’t continue to overlook black jeans.
Take a look at this next collage with me.
If you don’t have a pair of black jeans, and if you don’t even think you want a pair of black jeans…
I’m 99.99% sure that this collage will make your re-think your stance.
And if you already own and love black jeans, then I’m sure you are shaking you’re head at me in shame.  That’s okay, I’m shaking my head at myself too! 😉
I’ve been missing some major fashion opportunities girls!

class=”tr-caption” style=”text-align: center;”>1 HERE / 2 HERE/ 3 HERE / 4 from One Little Momma HERE / 5  HERE

I KNOW!
Again, if you already have black jeans, you are probably patting yourself on the back.
Good for you.

So if you don’t have them, are you jumping on the black jean train yet?
If not, I have one more pic that will surely push you off the fence….
this will be an outfit recreation in the very near future fo’ sho’.

source not accurate – if you know the source please leave it!

Case closed with that last pic, right?

I mean, I dare you to tell me now that you don’t want a pair of black jeans.
What?
That’s right. You can’t.So, I went on a quest for black jeans.  I actually ordered 8 pair right before the move to be delivered to the new house.  (I knew I was going to be busy for several weeks and not going to be going on mall field trips for hours to find the perfect jeans, so I thought having them at the house would be the best option.  When they all arrived, Chris may have thought otherwise.)  😉

So there’s the deal…
Out of the 8 I ordered, I hated 5 of them.
I can’t tell you exactly why I hated them, I just did.
But I tell you this, if they didn’t make me look as skinny as possible, they were on the “no” list.  🙂
If we’re going to be honest, that’s how it works with lots of my clothes.
Same with you?

These were my 3 favorites, and they are all under $65!
a.  Wit and Wisdom jeans HERE – $64

b.  Old Navy Rockstar Zipper Super Skinny jeans HERE – $36.94

c.  Mya Ankle Zipper jeans HERE – $59 

The ones that I ended up going with?
OPTION C.
The length was perfect on me, they were a great fit, and I really liked the zippers at the ankles.
For size reference, I got the 27.

I had actually ordered “b” for myself after my Old Navy post, but when I received them, they were too long.  I think that at 5’4″ I should have gotten the “short” option if I didn’t want to have to get them altered.

However, by the time I realized that they were too long for my liking, my 8 pair of jeans had arrived, and when I tried them on, I fell in love with THESE .
So the Old Navy pair went back (even though I think the short version would have worked on me), and I kept the Mya ankle zipper jeans.

So…….
I knew immediately what outfit I was going to put together first with the jeans.

Y’all remember the pantless picture of me in the blue plaid flannel on Friday (see below)?
Well, I decided to go ahead and put some pants on with it and see how I liked that look.

Cuz I’m crazy like that.

So I put this next outfit together in my mind.  And in my mind, it was DARLING.

shirt HERE / jeans HERE
earrings HERE / MK silver watch HERE / TB wrap bracelet HERE 
leopard flats Macy’s HERE and Piperlime HERE (limited sizes available) and Zappos HERE (limited sizes)
 (FYI:  The Lucky Emmie flats that I’ve featured before are on sale for $44 HERE.)

Darling, right????
Well…..
In real life I thought it was even better!!!!!!!!
Check this outfit out!!!!!
Simple. Easy. CUTE!
And I am absolutely smitten with the black denim!
I can’t wait to recreate several of the outfits in the Pinterest collage at the beginning of the post!

I thought the blue plaid looked great with the black jeans.  And then I threw in the leopard.
AND. OH. MY. WORD.
This entire outfit will be in heavy rotation this fall.
Look at me.
Now I love black jeans.

I know it’s hard to tell, but trust me,  the jeans were a great fit.
And at $59 they are a really good buy too!
Again, for size reference, I’m wearing a 27.
Click HERE .

My other favorites were the Wit and Wisdom jeans HERE.
For size reference, I was wearing a 4.
If you like jeans that sit a little higher on your waist, then these might be for you!
They were also longer and didn’t have zippers at the ankles.

And here are the rockstar zipper super skinny jeans from Old Navy (before I took them back).
I really think if I had ordered these in a “short” they would have been perfect!
Like I said in a previous post, they remind me of some much more expensive jeans you can find HERE (Joe’s) and a mid-priced version HERE from Treasure and Bond (these have amazing reviews!).  I really wish I would have ordered the Treasure and bond ones to try for myself.  That was a total oversight on my part.
Click HERE for the Old Navy version.
For size reference, I sized up and was wearing a size 6.

I liked the look better with the shirt out with the leopard flats in the previous picture…but I
did really love the cognac booties paired with the black jeans in this outfit too. The cognac booties above are from Old Navy.
But although I loved the color, I didn’t love the quality.

So here are some other cognac bootie options:

a) HERE / b) BP bootie HERE / c) sperry HERE
So, I’m dying to know?!?
Are you already President of the Black Jean Club?
Or are you a new member like me?Hi.  My name is Sheaffer.
And I recently discovered that I like black jeans.

Sound off in the comments!

xoxo,
Sheaffer 🙂

 

p.s.

Pin-spired is on Wednesday!
My outfit will involve my new Camo jacket!  WooHoo!

Filed Under: Fashion 84 Comments

You’ll Also Love

Style it Again, Sheaffer
Why You Need a Pair of Black Jeans That You Love!
1 Great Striped Sweater, Styled 4 Ways

Comments

  1. Mix and Match Mama says

    I mean…really and truly…you look so cute in your black jeans!! I used to have some too but they were donated a few years ago. This post totally has me thinking I need some more. Like yesterday.

    Reply

  2. Melissa Woycheese says

    I love my Old Navy black Rock Star super skinny jeans…so comfy! I just ordered a new pair for this year. They still are 30% off through today!

    Reply

  3. Kate @ Classy Living says

    They're a little higher than the price point you mentioned, but I just bought a pair of black jeans from White House Black Market that I'm obsessed with!! SO comfortable and appropriate enough to wear for work!

    Reply

  6. Natalie Zambreski says

    Black jeans are definitely seeming to be the new staple! I have a pair, but I am in the market for a new pair! I love the distressed look of the Old Navy pair!

    Reply

  7. Anonymous says

    I'm not a fan of black jeans. Scratch that. I wasn't a fan of black jeans, until just now. I'm going to buy your favorites with the ankle zip at the bottom. I already have the blue plaid shirt from when you talked about it last week, and I already have some leopard flats from when you talked about them last year. So I have to buy the jeans. Right? Yes, I have to.

    Reply

  8. Andrea lohman says

    Black jeans are good, but black coated jeans are even better. Black coated Vigoss jeans are the bomb! How did you miss these at the Nordies' anniversary sale?! Don't fret, you can still get them on amazon and they are only $28!

    Reply

  9. Maria says

    For once I feel ahead of the game as I have two pairs of black jeans that I love! Mine are both from Gap. I am loving the plaid and leopard look. I really must get myself a plaid shirt ASAP!

    Reply

  10. Mary Jensen says

    Love black jeans…have 2 pairs…my fav are Kut From the Kloth Diana Skinny jeans! (They have them at Nordstroms)…. Stretch and great fit! 🙂

    Reply

  11. Courtney says

    I bought my first pair of black jeans last year at Loft. The clincher for me was a pin where the girl styled her black jeans with a chambray shirt, striped heavy knit infinity scarf and white cons! I love them so much I ordered the ON rockstars a couple weeks ago!

    Reply

  12. Katie Smith says

    Never have been a fan of black jeans, but your outfit and the collages sure change my mind. The leopard shoes, plaid and black!!! Goodness gracious..it is awesome!!!

    Reply

  14. Lauren says

    So funny–black jeans are on my fall clothing shopping list! I am on the market for a good pair that won't stretch out at the knees. Will have to check out these options–thanks!

    Reply

  15. karate nurse says

    I definitely wear black jeans! I am a fan of Loft's skinny from a couple years ago and White House Black Market skinny, also from a couple years ago!

    Reply

  18. Angie says

    I bought a pair of black jeans last year, convinced myself I needed them. I have worn them exactly 0 times because I could never style them just right. Thank you for helping with that,I'm excited to pull out my black jeans and give them the second chance they deserve!

    Reply

  19. Daily Express says

    I can't believe you didn't own black jeans! Glad you have "seen the light" on this one and you will definitely get plenty of mileage out of them. Love your cute outfit with the plaid shirt and leopard flats. And is it wrong that when I saw your no-pants pic I wondered if you texted your handyman again to let him know?? LOL.
    Gina – On the Daily Express

    Reply

  20. Shawnee says

    I also bought a black pair last year and have never worn them. 🙁 Just maybe I will pull them out and wear them now with my chambray shirt and brown boots!!

    Reply

  21. melissabunny100 says

    When I think of black jeans, I think old lady "Lee" jeans that are faded wih white tennis shoes….UCK…I don't think I can do this one!

    Reply

  22. Jen Pogue says

    I love how you styled the blue plaid shirt with the black jeans and leopard shoes. I will be wearing that outfit as the weather gets cooler! 🙂

    Reply

  23. amy says

    I love my black jeans and now I'm thinking I might need a second pair. Just a reminder for all the teachers out there that your administrators probably think that black jeans are still jeans. Fridays only please.

    Reply

  24. Mugsy the Girl says

    I have two great pairs of black jeans – J. Crew Factory and one NYDJ. Once they start to fade then I have to let them go. In fact, I wear black jeans and people think they are pants. True story. I'm a rebel like that. Can't wait to style this outfit with my blue ON plaid shirt. Twinsies!

    Reply

  26. Anonymous says

    I bought a pair of black jeans on a whim last fall. I can't believe how much I have worn them. I don't think you will regret your purchase. I love that you get the comfort of jeans, but they look a little dressier.

    Reply

  27. Marty says

    I have a pair of black jeans that came from Old Navy a couple of years ago. They are hanging in my closet because I keep forgetting about them. You've inspired me, tho, and I'll be wearing those black jeans this week!

    Reply

  28. edensporch says

    Have to say on this one, I'm already there, you can be my VP. Black skinnies and tall cognac boots or nude heels for a night out but thinking I need some leopard in the day to day rotation. LOVE! And I wish the ON Rockstars worked for me – Had a pair in army green that I love the idea of but they just. aren't. long enough. 🙁

    Reply

  29. Brittany says

    I love my black jeans!!! I have 3 pair, one casual pair, once coated black, and one distressed pair. I wear them all the time, maybe even more than regular denim. I love your blog and I know you will love your black jeans, can't wait to get more ideas on how to wear them!!

    Reply

  31. As I Am says

    Don't stop at black, try grey, burgundy, bright blue, green etc…
    I personally don't own a denim coloured jean. But I defenitly want to add a distressed pair.

    Reply

  32. Anonymous says

    Don't have any but that will change! I will buy my trusty Always Skinny Gap jeans. I need to add that plaid shirt to my closet too!

    Reply

  33. Kim Kauffman says

    Your legs look a million miles long in those jeans! My mom got me a pair of black jeans for Christmas last year and at first I was like, huh, black jeans. Turns out I loved them and wore them ALL winter long. They have almost the look of leggings but the ease of jeans!

    Reply

  34. Amy McNamara says

    Last year I had a pair of skinny black courds that I wore all. the. time. So I knew I had to have a pair of black jeans this year, and I'm on the hunt. I saw a pair at Gap that I'd like to try, and I'll check out the ones you listed as well! Perfect timing for this post! LOVE your outfit with the leopard and flannel!!

    Reply

  35. priscilla says

    I have been wearing black jeans FOR EVER!! Maybe a little too long! I love them. You look so cute in your jeans. Such Inspiration, Pinspiration!!!

    Reply

  36. Anonymous says

    I love my black Paige skinny jeans! They are a couple years old and in perfect shape still and haven't faded at all. You'll wear yours all the time!

    Reply

  38. Jordyn Brown says

    I've long been a lover of black jeans (when you own a black lab, you need all the help you can get to cover up shedding issues!)
    My favorites have definitely always been the Rockstar jeans from Old Navy, though I have never tried the pair with the zipper pockets, I've always thought they were too edgy for me!
    I may have to explore some of the other options you posted, you've got me intrigued!

    xoxo, SS
    http://www.TheSouthernStylista.blogspot.com

    Reply

  39. Leah says

    I bought my first pair of black skinny jeans last winter….and I wear them at least once a week! I bought my pair from American Eagle and they still look as good as the day I bought them – they haven't faded a bit. Love this post!!

    Reply

  41. abby says

    I too was hesitant to jump on the black jean bandwagon but finally broke down and bought a pair last year and ended up wearing them a lot. Excited to see how you style them this fall/winter.

    Random question…..after reading your blog for awhile now….and after hearing you rave about the Sam Edleman leopard flats….and seeing all the cute things you wear with them…..I finally broke down and bought a pair about a month ago- which was a stretch for this SAHM on a budget. I'm SO glad I did and have LOVED them. Just wondering why you have been wearing the pointy toed, Steve Maddens more lately. I know they each have a little different look to them (one pointy and one more round). Just an observation and hoping I'm not already "so 2013" :). LOVE the blog!

    Reply

    • Sheaffer says

      Hi Abby! I still have and STILL LOVE the Sam Edelman's. In fact, they are way more comfy than the pointy toe version, so I actually wear those just as much. And no worries, you are still very current! 🙂
      xoxo,
      Sheaffer 🙂

      Reply

  42. Audrey Davis says

    Your blog is so spot on with fashion!! 🙂 Jbrand 811 black jeans are my favs…just in case you are looking for other pairs!! Love all your posts!!

    Reply

  43. V @ X-tremely V says

    So glad you joined the black jean gang! lol! I have loved black jeans for years! They really do go with everything and can easily be dressed up or down 🙂

    Reply

  44. Anonymous says

    The black jeans look amazing on you and I love it with the plaid and leopard!! I think I need this whole outfit! Did I miss where you got the leopard flats from? Would love to know as I have been searching for some! Great post!

    Reply

  45. Lisa C says

    I like black jeans. However, they have a shelf life (if you wear them frequently) similar to that of a white tee. They should be replaced every year and honestly don't get better with age! On another topic, I must be about your size but taller (5'6"). I am 52. I have thighs, not skinny thighs like some and not big thick apple thighs like others. So I always wonder what is the correct "tightness" in the thighs. Maybe you should do a post along the lines of leggings aren't pants instead it's along the lines of how tight is too tight? I adore my Wit and Wisdom jeans (I have those in blue and black) because they are tight enough without being too tight.

    Reply

  46. theKfam says

    Love black jeans because they are like leggings, but thicker and more forgiving when wearing a top that doesn't come down far enough. Cause we all know leggings aren't pants, but black jeans are!!!

    Reply

    • Sheaffer says

      Hi Lindsay! The links for the flats are directly above the collage I put together with the pictures of the blue flannel, the black jeans, the leopard flats, and the accessories!!! 🙂
      xoxo,
      Sheaffer 🙂

      Reply

  49. ljones83 says

    I really like the Old Navy black jeans with the zippers! I may or may not have just gone to Pinterest and pinned 5 black jeans outfits!

    Reply

  51. Lisa Burris says

    LOFT seems to be on a black jeans (and cords) kick recently. I was on the site looking for black pants for a conference I'm attending soon and could hardly find any among the tons of black jeans and cords. Just thought you might be interested – I know you love LOFT like I do! 🙂 I, however, am just not sold on the black jeans thing…your's was a pretty good sell, but I already have black slacks, black leggings and some skinny navy pants – just don't think I'd get much use out of a pair of black jeans!

    Reply

  52. Brooks Matthews says

    Black jeans are my jam!! And Old Navy Rockstars are my go-to's! So comfortable! I am a 6th grade math teacher and I pretty much live in ON black Rockstars Monday-Thursday! If I'm not wearing a dress, you can bet I'm wearing black jeans!

    Reply

  53. Blue-Eyed Bride says

    I have worn black jeans almost every day for the past two cold weather seasons. My favorite pair is from banana republic and I seriously LIVE in them. They are winter/fall's version of white jeans for me 🙂 the uniform! Love these looks!

    Reply

  54. Karen Stopnicki says

    Now I need to get a pair! I haven't worn black jeans in, well, YEARS! Glad that they are back and darker and cuter. BTW, my husband still has a pair from when they used to be in style, and they still fit him. That makes me laugh.

    Reply

  55. Katie O'Brien says

    I was hoping you would do a post on black jeans soon!! I ordered the Old Navy black pants. Also, I was checking around for the Steve Madden leopard flats on different websites, and on stevemadden.com you can enter the code SHOPSEPT (it ends tomorrow) and get 15% off AND free shipping!! I got these for $65!

    Reply

  57. Mary Jensen says

    Interested in some styling of black wax coated jeans…I am 52 and a teacher, wondering if they are too edgy for work…Sheaffer??

    Reply

  58. CampDallas says

    Ohmygoodness! Yes!!! I bought black jeggings at Gap outlet this year. They give the illusion of jeans, but whoa-oh-so-comfy. I am going to pair them up with my denim tunic from loft and leopard flats. Because let's be serious…that's totally something you would do. And you're stinkin' adorable & would never steer me wrong. 🙂

    Reply

  59. LauraG. says

    I have been rocking the black jeans too!
    I am so in love with the Madewell skinny high risers.
    Totally worth the price….cost per wear will play out since you will never want to take them off! They never bag out and make you look slim and sexy! They are awesome!

    Reply

  60. Cathy and Marshall says

    I have a pair of black Wit and Wisdom jeans that I love! They are easily my most comfortable pair of jeans. I'm six feet tall, so they are a little short on me – but either I wear them with boots and it doesn't matter, or I just go for the cropped look with ballet flats. I cannot wait to (hopefully) fit into them again once I have a baby this fall!

    Reply

  61. Amber says

    I'm curious if you tried on a pair of black jeans from LOFT? I got a pair delivered last week and am excited to wear them! Like you, I've seen so many cute black jean outfits on Pinterest, and they are so flattering!
    The blue plaid old navy shirt is on its way to me and I got the Sam Edelman leopard flats during the spring Nordstrom sale, so I'm excited to recreate this outfit. 🙂

    Reply

  62. April Parrish says

    I love black jeans and have been wearing for a couple of years! Love the styles you featured today! The plaid and the leopard look great on you!

    Reply

  64. Leslie Roberts Clingan says

    Ya talked me into the blue flannel! It is on it's way. I did order a large because of the reviews warning it shrinks. Definitely washing on delicate in cold water and air drying. Love your fun, energetic, conversational writing style and blog. Feels like we are friends.

    Reply

  65. Meet Lindsay says

    I actually have black jeans AND I ordered that flannel shirt because of you. I went with it just because I thought it would look good with my black jeans. It should be delivered tomorrow. And I also got the black cord skinny pants from GAP that the shirt might go with.

    Reply

  66. Jessica says

    Love black fitted black pants, but i have a hard time finding the perfect black jean but I'm on the hunt. In the meantime, I recently bought a black fitted pair of pants with small black polka dots from j crew factory called the gigi pant. They almost like leggings, so comfy and soft. They go with pretty much everything. Check them out!

    Reply

  69. Erica says

    Add a leopard scarf to the denim shirt and black jeans and you pretty much have my go to outfit. At least once a week when it finally gets cooler.

    Reply

  70. Aja says

    I honestly can't believe you didn't have black skinny jeans! I have to buy a new pair every so often bc I wear them so often in fall and winter (despite washing with Woolite Darks, most do fade).

    Reply

  71. Anonymous says

    I have a pair of black skinny jeans and I love them. They were the perfect pants to wear to work when I taught special needs children for MISD because we could only wear jeans on Fridays. But different colored skinny jeans were a loophole some of us found. It was a way to dress up but still be comfortable and wear cute shoes.

    Reply

  72. Anonymous says

    I bought the old navy Rockstar black jeans last fall. I loved them at first but after about 2 washes the turned totally faded. After reading your post I think I'll try again but stay clear of the old navy variety.

    Reply

  73. Erica Tidwell says

    Anyone know what kind of boots those are in the pic with the white tunic and jean top? They are perfect and I need them. P.s. I love my black steethcy Calvin Klein jeans only 25 bucks at Costco right now

    Reply

  74. Mary says

    I absolutely love my black skinny jeans, so much so I bought a second pair with rhinestones on the back pockets! I wear them so much, I can't remember wearing my blue ones! I pair them with a chambray shirt like you did. I also have two chambray shirts – one has bronzy metal bubbles on the shoulders, very cute. I also wear a red/black flannel shirt and dress it up with a shinny statement necklace. In the spring/fall I wear them with simple black flip flops and add a cute white shirt then top with a pink, melon or teal long cotton sweater. Keep spreading the word, I've had mine for two years and get so many compliments; even my daughter said she loved my black jeans!

    Reply

  75. Unknown says

    I know your post is a little old, but found it through Pinterest and thought I'd add my two cents. 🙂
    I've been in love with black jeans for the past 2 years! I've actually tried several myself, but FINALLY found the perfect ones at Express. I've probably bought at least 4 pairs by now. I have tried to air dry them as much as possible to avoid fading, and if you do these could last quite awhile. I just have several so I can rotate. Here is the link for $79, but Express always has coupons, so I've never spent more than maybe $40. Enjoy! http://www.express.com/clothing/women/black-mid-rise-skinny-jean/pro/7016311/cat1730040

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SHEAFFER TOLD ME TO RUNS ADS PROVIDED BY A THIRD PARTY SPONSOR AND USES AFFILIATE LINKS AND COOKIES WITHIN THIS SITE. PURCHASING AN ITEM THROUGH A LINK FROM SHEAFFER TOLD ME TO OR SHEAFFER TOLD ME TO SOCIAL MEDIA (FACEBOOK, TWITTER, PINTEREST, INSTAGRAM VIA LIKETKIT) MAY RESULT IN A COMMISSION. CURRENTLY, THIS SITE USES REWARDSTYLE, SHOPSTYLE, AND AMAZON LINKS. MERELY CLICKING ON A LINK DOES NOT RESULT IN A COMMISSION, BUT IF AN ITEM IS PURCHASED AS A RESULT OF THE LINK, A COMMISSION IS EARNED. OCCASIONALLY THE BLOG ACTIVITIES ARE SPONSORED (EX. A PARTICULAR BRAND MIGHT WANT TO BE FEATURED OR MIGHT DESIRE TO HAVE A SPECIFIC ITEM HIGHLIGHTED). SPONSORED POSTS AND CONTENT WILL ALWAYS BE DISCLOSED WITHIN THE BODY OF THE POST. IF A PRODUCT HAS BEEN GIFTED, IT WILL BE DISCLOSED WITH "C/O". PLEASE KNOW THAT I TURN DOWN MORE SPONSORED POSTS THAN I ACCEPT. I DO NOT FEATURE ALL PRODUCTS THAT HAVE BEEN GIVEN TO ME, ONLY THE ONES THAT I TRULY LOVE! IF YOU HAVE ANY SPECIFIC QUESTIONS ABOUT MY DISCLOSURES OR AFFILIATE LINKS, PLEASE FEEL FREE TO CONTACT ME DIRECTLY VIA E-MAIL AT PINTERESTTOLDMETO@YAHOO.COM. IN ADDITION, IF YOU SEE ANY IMAGES OF YOURS ON MY SITE THAT ARE NOT PROPERLY CREDITED, PLEASE E-MAIL ME DIRECTLY AND I WILL EITHER REMOVE THEM OR CREDIT THEM IMMEDIATELY PER YOUR REQUEST.

Copyright © 2025 Sheaffer Told Me To