Today’s post is one of my favorite posts each and every month. Today I’m going to share your Top 12 picks from January.
Not surprisingly, many of y’alls Top 12 picks are in my top picks for the month as well. All of the items I’m featuring today are items that I added to my own closet or makeup drawer (or already owned), and because of that they are items that you will continue to see on the blog as long as they are in stock.
The picks that made this month’s top list are from Nordstrom, Amazon, Avara, and Colleen Rothschild. And great news! Everything (except for the last pair of jeans) that made the Top 12 is below $100.
So, what were our favorites for the month? Let’s look and see…
Click HERE for links to all of the items seen below.

1) heart sweatshirt / I first showed you this heart sweatshirt in a collage. Click HERE for everything you see below, and then just click on the picture of the item you are interested in.

I ordered the sweatshirt for myself after finding it for the collage…
This tiny heart sweatshirt is just the kind of top I love to throw on with jeans and sneakers. There’s a light fleece on the inside that’s soft, but not super hot. Since the sweatshirt isn’t thick, you can either wear it out or tuck it in without it being too bulky. For size reference, I’m wearing a medium. If between sizes, I would suggest sizing up because the fit is a bit narrow.
tiny heart sweatshirt / blingy heart earrings / similar cross necklace / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

*****
2) heart cardi / This cute little cropped heart cardigan was an immediate HECK YES for me. The site says it runs large, but I actually think it runs a tad small. I’m in my regular size medium, but if you are between sizes I would say to size up.
I think it’s sweet because of the color and hearts. If pink isn’t your thing, it also comes in a soft powder blue with cream hearts and a creamy white with really soft blush hearts.
If you want some modern denim, these wide leg ankle jeans will fit the bill. I’m loving them. They’re a very soft denim with front pockets, wide legs, and a cropped hem. I’m wearing my regular size 4 (not a petite), but I’m wondering if I would like more of a cropped look, so I’m thinking of trying them in a petite too.
cropped heart cardigan / double heart earrings / wide leg ankle jeans / sneakers

And here it is with the cream jeans…
cropped heart cardigan / double heart earrings / cream wide leg jeans / sneakers

*****
3) multicolor charm necklace / I just recently got this necklace and started showing it, but y’all have loved it.
This short sleeve sweater is great and so versatile. I will wear it by itself all the way through spring but will also layer it under jackets right now. It comes in a “vanilla white” too, but I couldn’t resist this gorgeous “tulip red” color. It’s a tiny bit of a boxy fit, but it’s not too boxy at all. The sleeve length goes down to the elbow, which I love. For size reference, I’m wearing a small.
short sleeve sweater / blingy heart earrings / multicolor charm necklace / gold bracelet stack / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

**********
4) Face Oil #9 / There’s a Valentine’s Day Sale going on right now, and you can get $25.50 off right now!
The Face Oil #9 is a product that I absolutely cannot live without. Like I would absolutely freak out if they ever discontinued it. If you’ve never tried it, you really need to! I’ve given it as a gift several times, and everybody that I’ve ever given it to is now a devoted user.
When I first started using it years and years ago I only used it at night, but now I use it in the morning too. I just mix it with my moisturizer and my skin absolutely drinks it up. YOU WILL LOVE IT. It is a must have product for me for sure.
Colleen touts it as the ultimate in skin luxury, and I have to agree. It improves radiance. RADIANCE!

*****
5) sneakers / I bought these sneakers several months ago, and I’m still wearing the heck out of them. They are PERFECT for fall and winter because of the color and material. I think they are super comfy and true to size.
This sweater combines a bold pink and bold orange together for this vibrant sweater with fun wavy stripes. It’s thicker and much warmer than the above cardi. The colors absolutely pop and are so eye-catching! I do think it runs a bit big. I’m wearing a medium and like the fit, but I think a small would be just fine too.
wavy striped sweater / skinny hoop earrings / coin toggle necklace / gold bracelet stack / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

striped cardi / skinny hoop earrings / coin toggle necklace / gold bracelet stack / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

This set has a simple crewneck and super casual. I’m wearing the brown here, but it comes in several other color options. The piping is a nice design detail, and I of course love the drawstring waist and pockets. It’s giving sporty chic vibes. For size reference, I’m wearing a small.
2 piece lounge set / chunky hoop earrings / coin toggle necklace / similar leopard slippers

*****
6) striped sweatshirt / This striped sweatshirt is going to be a closet staple for me. It’s got an oversized slouchy fit, and I love it. This one is a creamy ivory with a navy stripe, but it also comes in a navy with a white stripe. It’s really soft and it has a little bit of stretch (which is awesome). For size reference, I’m wearing the medium. The small would definitely fit too, but I liked this fit.
striped sweatshirt / blingy heart earrings / multicolor charm necklace / gold bracelet stack / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

*****
7) modal 2-piece set / This is a 2-piece set that I’m dang near obsessed with. It’s pretty much perfection.
I’m obviously wearing the black here (and love it), but I’ve actually sent this one back and exchanged it for the apricot. Wearing black with a Golden Retriever at home just isn’t the best idea. 😉 I also love the grey, the brown, and the khaki.
It’s a modal jersey, it’s crazy soft, and it’s very stretchy. YOU WILL LOVE IT. The material is great quality, and the set is well made. For size reference, I’m wearing a small.
oversized sweatshirt and wide leg pants set / Dolce Vita sneakers

And although this set didn’t make the Top 12 list, it’s getting a spot today because it was one of my favorite personal finds.
I’m wearing the light khaki in a medium (I think I would actually prefer the fit of a small), but it’s still sooooooooooo good. I totally compare it to the look and quality of Spanx, but for a much smaller price. I’m wearing it here with slippers, but I’ll definitely throw on UGGs or sneakers with it and run around town.
These are the only kinds of things I want to be wearing from now until April.
2-piece lounge set / chunky hoop earrings / coin toggle necklace / matte gold bracelet stack / similar leopard slippers

*****
8) ankle jeans / NOW LADIES…THESE JEANS. They are so SO good.
They were recommended to me by my sister, and I knew I had to have them for myself because they looked so great on her. They look pretty short on the model, but they hit me just where I like them to (just showing a bit of ankle). I’m 5’4″ with long legs and no torso (to give you some reference).
They fit like a glove. But like a really comfy and stretchy glove that still has some structure to it.
I think these are super flattering, and I’m so glad I took a chance on this to new (to me) brand. Thanks for the suggestion, Conner! #connertoldmeto
They run true to size. I’m wearing a 4.
ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

Here are several outfits with the jeans…
Do you want to be festive, but don’t want to wear hearts? Well then, this rose sweater is for you. IT IS DARLING!!! The pink is beautiful and bright and happy, and the graphic red rose is such a fun design. There’s also a creamy white option with a blush pink rose.
I love the subtle puff sleeve and the thick banded hem. I think it’s very flattering.
Now, this sweater is pricey. But as I always say, I tend to add a pricey piece to my closet here and there (if I LOVE it), and it always seems to work out. I find the pieces that I truly love are the ones that get worn the most, so the cost per wear ends up justifying the higher price tag.
For size reference, I’m wearing a medium.
rose sweater / blingy heart earrings / similar cross necklace / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

This cutie sweatshirt is vibrant red with a pink metallic LOVE in bubble letters. This one has a fit that’s a bit slouchier, but it does have a banded hem. It can be worn pulled down, with the band around the hips, or with a half tuck. For size reference, I’m wearing a medium. I definitely need a medium in the chest, but the shoulders are a bit wide for me (but I know a small would be too small).
LOVE sweatshirt / double heart earrings / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

I pulled this short sleeve heart cardi straight out of a vacuum sealed bag, which is why it’s a wrinkled mess. It’s very oversized and I think the fit is kind fun like this, but I would definitely prefer a small (because I think the small will still be oversized). For size reference, I’m wearing a medium.
It also comes in a red with white hearts and a white with red hearts. It comes in lots of solid colors too.
short sleeve heart cardi / blingy heart earrings / similar cross necklace / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

This playful cardi is ribbed and features little stripes, some colorblocking, and some cutie little hearts. It’s definitely fitted, but although I typically prefer a more relaxed style, I actually like the fit of this one. I’m wearing a medium here and it’s too small for me to wear it all buttoned up, but I like the look worn open over a basic tee.
ribbed heart cardi / white tee / blingy heart earrings / similar cross necklace / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

Okay. SO THIS IS CUTE.
A little blue and white pin stripe with tiny red hearts. YES, PLEASE.
It’s a crisp cotton button up. It’s totally classic, but with some festive flare.
For size reference, I’m wearing a medium.
This one will be great with white jeans too.
heart button up / blingy heart earrings / similar cross necklace / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

If you’re looking for something a little more roomy, this is a great choice. It’s thick, warm, and can be worn open (like you see below) or all buttoned up like a regular sweater. The hearts are different sizes, different colors, and perfectly whimsical. For size reference, I’m wearing a medium, but I think a small would be a better fit (and still roomy).
chunky heart cardi / white tee / blingy heart earrings / similar cross necklace / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

This pink and white striped sweater is precious. It’s very lightweight, so it would be great layered under a denim or military jacket, but I think you could wear it by itself all the way into summer. I love the red piping around the collar, sleeves, and hem. For size reference, I’m wearing a medium.
pink and white striped sweater / double heart earrings / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

February is here, and I’m totally dying over this fair isle heart sweater. It’s a beautiful soft pink with vibrant red accents, and it combines hearts and bows in the most adorable fair isle pattern. And look at the little hearts around the sleeves and the hem! For size reference, I’m wearing a medium, but I think I would prefer a small in this one.
fair isle heart sweater / multicolor beaded hoop earrings / coin toggle necklace / ankle bootcut jeans / sneakers

*****
9) frayed hem wide leg jeans / Now let’s talk about these frayed hem boot cut jeans, NOW ON SALE. The leg is slightly flared, and I love the frayed hem. I actually think they are kind of like a super subtle wide leg. They have the mold and hold technology that we all love, and they will make you feel like a million bucks! Again, I for sure feel taller and skinnier with them on. True to size, I’m wearing a 4.
sweater / frayed hem boot cut jeans / suede booties / hoops / coin necklace / bracelet stack

Here they are with a different top (that’s now sold out)…
boatneck sweater / frayed hem boot cut jeans / suede booties / hoops / coin toggle necklace / matte gold bracelet stack

*****
10) multicolor beaded earrings / Here are just a couple of outfits styled with the earrings… And they are ON SALE right now! These earrings will be great all year round.


And here’s a close up of the earrings!
multicolor beaded hoop earrings

***********
11) Dual Enzyme Polish / $27.50 → regularly $55.00 (that’s 50% off right now!)
If the 50% OFF deal has expired (fingers crossed it hasn’t!), you can always use the code STMT20 for 20% OFF.
My absolute favorite new routine right now is to wash my face at night before I get in the shower (with the balm) and then I rub the Dual Enzyme Polish in circulation motions all over my face. It’s grainy and gently exfoliates LIKE A DREAM. Then I hop in the shower with it on. I leave it on during the shower, and then at the end of the shower, I do a little more circular rubbing and then splash water all over my face to get it all off. Pat your skin dry and YOUR SKIN WILL BE STUPID SOFT and feel incredibly soft and clean. It’s such a treat.

*****
12) heart slippers / I only showed these slippers in a collage, but y’all bought them up! I actually have these from a couple of years ago and love them so much (I have the pumpkins too).
treat yourself (just click on pics you are interested in after clicking this link)

*****
13) Kut jeans / These kick wash flare jeans look cropped on the model, but they are closer to full length on me (I’m 5’4″ with long legs for my height and no torso). For these colder months, I actually like this length. However, I might end up shortening them for spring and summer. Since they are a frayed hem, I’m thinking I’m just going to take a pair of scissors to them and take off a couple of inches. For size reference, I’m wearing a size 4.
striped cardi / coin toggle necklace / gold bracelet stack / kick wash flare jeans / booties

*****
So I have to know! Do you have a favorite from the month? That’s all for today, y’all!



Amy Azza says
Hi Shaeffer, question on the CR Dual Enzyme Polish. Are you using that every night, or just several times per week? Can you use it in the morning, or just at night? I use the Face Oil No. 9 every night with the CR extreme recovery cream, and I will try that in the morning with my morning moisturizer as well. Thank you!
Sheaffer says
Hi, Amy! I’m using the dual enzyme polish at night like 3x a week. I guess you could use it in the morning, but I never have. It’s an exfoliator, so for some reason I’ve only ever considered using it at night, but I’m not sure why?!? I LOVE it so much. It makes my skin feel so so soft. xoxo
Amy Azza says
thank you Shaeffer! I love it so much too and I agree, it makes my skin sooo soft.
Shay Shull says
I LOVE when you share your Top 12 each month! I’m always curious about which things were most loved.
Erika Slaughter says
I just bit the bullet and snagged some brown sneakers! It was about time!