Click HERE for Bachelor recaps from previous weeks.
You know you don’t want to miss when Olivia made this grand proclamation….
right before she was sent home.

I think we just have to trust and believe (apparently I’ve been doing too much Shaun T. lately) that she was evacuated because of the impending hurricane.
The episode opens up with Ben heading back to his hometown of Warsaw, Indiana.
Before seeing the girls, he met up with his CUTE AS PIE parents at a local diner.
I’ll tell you this:
THIS BOY LOVES HIS MAMA.
He loves his daddy too.
But I was a little surprised that Mike and Carol weren’t there.
#imposters
He gave his parents a Cliff’s Notes version of the 6 girls left.
And now I’m going to give you a Cliff’s Notes version of Ben’s Cliff’s notes.
Part of him likes Becca, part of him doesn’t.
He thinks JoJo is HOT.
Emily is wayyyyyy better than that other girl that looked a lot like her.
Calia is pretty, but scared.
Amanda has kids and is “shockingly beautiful”.
While he’s wrapping up his time with his parents, the girls are walking through Warsaw, admiring the charming houses, frolicking in the breathtaking foliage, and just soaking up the crisp and fresh air.
SERIOUSLY.
It could not be more picturesque.
If you watched, tell me part of you didn’t want to pack your entire family up and relocate to Warsaw immediately.
I’m betting the crime rate is low, the produce tastes better (I’m guessing), and as you’ll see in a bit they have a stellar after school program.
All the girls felt the same way I did.
They all want to move there immediately and start popping out babies while their dreamy hubby runs for city council.
BECAUSE HE TOTALLY SHOULD.
Seriously.
He should at least run for a spot on the tourism board….because with all of the beauty and splendor I just mentioned in the great city of Warsaw…look what made it to the Warsaw welcome sign.
Welcome to Warsaw. The Orthopedic Capital.
Anyhoo.
Becca went on and on about how much she loves Warsaw.
And you know what she loves the most about Warsaw?
It’s not a farm in Iowa.
#i’llbehereallnight
I do feel like I need to point out to all of the girls that Ben does not currently live in Warsaw.
HE LIVES IN DENVER.
Ben picked all the girls up in a boat. He was comin’ in a little hot, and Caila single-handedly kept him from crashing smack dab into the dock.
He took them to the DARLING little water front property that they would be staying in for the week, and they all sat down on the couches to chat.
I’m guessing there is NO WAY anybody could have predicted what Ben was going to say next.
Ben told the girls that his parents lived just across the way.
He then warned them to not be peeking in their windows because they are “still very much in love.”
EW.
Ben.
Your parents are in love, we get it.
LAUREN GOT THE FIRST 1:1
In a change up that I don’t think we’ve ever seen before, Ben just turned to Lauren and asked her out on a date.
NO DATE CARD?
WHUT?
I felt like the axis of the earth had shifted.
.
Ben told Lauren she had 30 minutes to get ready.
And she was freaking out, although she already had a full face of make-up, eyelashes for days, and her extensions in.
#calmdownlauren
They hopped in a red vintage truck and rode around town.
He showed her his elementary school, his high school, his church, and the local movie theater….
and he told a cute little story about his first kiss at said theater.
It was all very charming and endearing.
They pulled up at the youth club where he used to work and I gotta say,
Ben was IN. HIS. ELEMENT.
This guy really does seem to be as sweet and wonderful as we all think he is!
The coach challenged a kid named Ronnie (who is apparently a Warsaw legend) to a half court shot. If he got it, Ben had to kiss Lauren.
Well, Ronnie SUNK THE SHOT.
I’m telling you, NOTHIN’ BUT NET! This kid was the star of the show!
Go Ronnie! Go Ronnie! Go Ronnie!
So he sunk it, and then this happened.
Look at all of the little girl’s faces in the background.
I imagine that is how many a Bachelor watching party looked as well.
Ben then told Lauren there was about to be a huge surprise. He walked in with Paul George and George Hill, and I was like “who?”
Well, they are apparently pretty big deals and a couple of the star players from the Indiana Pacers.
The kids were all pretty excited, but if somebody tells me there is about to be a huge surprise, my fingers are crossed for queso.
Ben then played basketball with a toddler in a diaper (what is the little guy doing at after school care?) and then counseled a little fella found crying in the corner. He sat down beside him, asked his name, and then talked him into participating with everybody.
It was sweet as can be, and Ben was super genuine, but part of me wonders if a producer pinched that poor kid really hard or stole his after school snack to induce those tears.
Cue Lauren’s ovaries exploding in 3…..2…..1…….
That night they headed to Ben’s favorite local dive bar with his friends, and Ben was just as happy as can be having Lauren by his side.
In summary, this date made me really like Lauren!
And Ben.
And Lauren and Ben together.
Lauren declared, “I’m not in love with Ben, the Bachelor. I’m in love with Ben from Warsaw, Indiana.” Cue the oohs and ahhs!
I really wish we would have seen more with the friends at the bar…because I’m guessing they would have had some stories about middle school and high school Ben that we all would have loved to hear over some shots!
NEXT 1:1
Who: JoJo
What it Says: Let’s find love in the windy city.
Although some of the girls did point out that it is in fact windy in Warsaw, they headed to Chicago anyway. And Ben lived out a life-long dream. He was cute and totally fan-girling about the fact that he was on Wrigley field.
So, they did some throwin’ and some hittin’…
And then they did a little kissin’.
And although not pictured, she grabbed his butt.
And, listen. I know I’m not a sports expert, but I think butt grabbing is 1/2 way between
1st and second base.
#gojojo
They seemed very at ease and like they were actually having fun and possibly falling for each other.
They returned that night and had dinner on the field.
JoJo revealed a little more of herself to Ben, which Ben liked, and she ended the night by saying she’s “Team Ben.”
Which was precious.
GROUP DATE
Who: Caila, Amanda, and Becca
What it Says: I don’t remember. And I’m too lazy to google it to find out. What it should have said was “Get Ready, Because This is Going to Suck. Hard.”
Nobody wanted a group date…. but Caila, Amanda, and Becca got it.
They rode in canoes, flew kites, and sat on some hay.
WORST GROUP DATE EVER.
This is what happened during their 1:1 time:
Caila is OVER group dates and told Ben that she pictures herself as moss and has always “been trying to find the perfect tree to grow with.”, Amanda’s ready to see her kids (of course), and Becca is really needing some affirmation. She whispers “just don’t blindside me”.
That, my friends, is a little something I like to call foreshadowing.
The one redeeming part about this date was that there was a rather large cheese tray in the barn where the two other girls would wait when Ben was off doing 1:1 time with the other girl.
I would have been ALL OVER that cheese plate.
I would have happily eaten plenty of cheese to cover up any feelings I was having.
Ben returned and then explained to the group that this rose he was about give out was the most important rose in the history of roses.
Not only was the girl that got the rose going to be guaranteed a home town date next week, but she would also get 1:1 time with him the rest of the night.
WHERE IS HARRISON? THIS SEEMS LIKE IT SHOULD BE HIS JOB!
Ben gave the rose to Amanda, and Becca and Calia were crushed.
So, where did Amanda and Ben go on their date the rest of the night?
The possibilities were endless!
Well.
He took her to McDonald’s.
#didyouknowthattheyarenowservingselectbreakfastitemsfordinner?
#becausetheyare
#andnowyouknow
And as long as we are talking about it…their breakfast burritos are LEGIT.
They worked the drive thru, and I felt super sorry for the people in the drive thru.
If I’m running through McDonald’s to get a Dr. Pepper (with extra ice) and a large fry, I DO NOT want the general American public to know about it. I want to eat it in private thankyouverymuch.
Then they ordered some Egg McMuffins and fries and channeled Lady and The Tramp.
TOTALLY cheezy, but just to be clear, I would eat a McDonald’s french fry like this with a stranger if I had to.
Look at these two.
#McCouple
After they ate BREAKFAST FOR DINNER (because you now, McDonald’s does that now) ;), they headed to the Warsaw carnival.
I learned something about Ben on this date.
He shares my fear of carnivals where the rides are put up in one day.
#deathtraps
#nothankyou
That means Emily’s got the last 1:1.
Card says: Home is where the heart is.
When Emily found out she got the last 1:1, the girl straight up bawled out of sheer happiness.
Emily and Ben hopped on his pontoon, and he took her to his parent’s house.
Emily looked so cute with her fringy scarf, but man oh man she BOMBED with the parents.
She appeared sooooooooooo young.
Like middle school young.
This isn’t a direct quote, but it pretty much sums up her time with the family.
She rambled on and on an on, and basically said, “I hate carrots, but I love cheerleading.”
She then said, and this is a direct quote: “I feel like I’m so average at everything in life….”
When talking with Ben’s dad, she goes on to tell him that she would love to just sit around and watch movies all day.
Emily, Emily, Emily.
Of course we would all love to do that, but we would never admit it.
I guess that’s something that comes with a little maturity.
😉
Ben’s mom was all, “Um, NO M’AM. My Ben is not going to marry a carrot hating cheerleader.”
Well, she didn’t say that, but she did get all teary…and I think it was because she was genuinely nervous about what all of the other girls were going to be like.
If this was a calculated move on Ben’s part, well then I say “Well played.”
After saying good-bye to the parents, she hopped back on the pontoon with Ben.
She said “Where am I going? You’re not taking me home are you?”
Yep, Emily. It’s time to go back to Twin Enterprises.
But I’ve gotta give it to her, even though she broke down with the other girls (who all seem to genuinely like and care for each other)….
she handled herself perfectly in the limo!
I mean seriously, other people need to take notes.
She was mature and lovely.
She said, “The fact that I even got to come here and meet someone so amazing is an absolute blessing.”
WAIT, TWIN!
Don’t go!
More of this and less “I hate vegetables” could have bought you another week!
Rose Ceremony.
The girls are standing there, waiting on Ben.
Caila senses “something isn’t right”….and I’m all, I KNOW!
What are these garments you are wearing over your pretty dresses?
WHEN WEARING COCKTAIL DRESSES, COATS ARE NOT ALLOWED IN BACHELOR WORLD.
That’s Rule #28.
(Just fyi: a couple of more rules you may or may not be familiar with:
Rule #34:
When on hometown dates you must run and straddle the Bachelor when you first see him.
Please refer to Kaitlyn.
Rule #16:
When in a foreign country, if you walk by a stone wall, you must throw your date up against it and kiss her passionately. This is also referred to as “Arie’s law”.
Rule #52:
Harrison can do no wrong.
Caila, Amanda, JoJo, and Lauren B. all got roses.
Becca was sent home.
While walking her out, Becca asked “Why did you do this?” (blind side her) and then wondered in the limo why she keeps putting herself in this position.
We are wondering that as well, sweetheart.
So…NEXT WEEK is hometown dates and it looks like it’s gonna be CRAZY GOOD.
Like brothers speaking out of turn good.
#let’spouroneoutfordesire’sbrother
Remember him with Sean?
WHOAH!
One more Bachelor related item…
I noticed on Ben’s instagram that he was highlighting this bracelet that he’s been wearing all season.
If you want to read about the thought behind it and learn what the proceeds go to, head to his instagram post here!
I had a couple of readers e-mail me about this, so thank y’all for making sure I knew about it!
If you usually only come around here on Wednesdays for the Bachelor Recaps, you might want to check out my Monday post too!
It’s Joanna Gaines Told Me To, and I recreated an outfit that I pinned with one of Joanna Gaines’ outfits from one of her photo shoots.
And you can still go HERE to enter my instagram contest for a military jacket. Rules found on the instagram caption !
And don’t forget, the Nordstrom Winter Clearance Sale is going on right now!
Click HERE to shop the entire sale.
Click HERE to shop everything for women!
Click HERE to shop North Face on sale for the entire family!
Click HERE to shop UGG on sale for the entire family!
Erika Slaughter says
Girl!! You and me both! We could have shared the cheese platter. Ha! That group date seemed extra awkward. I was so close to googling "homes for sale in Warsaw Indiana" because the whole town just looked so cute!!
Anonymous says
Thanks to these recaps, I don't even mind waking up on Wednesday mornings. #imposters had me laughing out loud. And I noticed the coat thing too! So funny!
Mix and Match Mama says
I hate that we won't be seeing each other anymore. I'm moving to Warsaw. Like today. xo
Anonymous says
Warsaw born and raised! And Ben and his parents are wonderful as well! We'd love to have you! 🙂
Unknown says
I've always loved reading your Bachelor posts, but especially this one because I'm from Warsaw! I loved that y'all loved our town as much as we do! Ben is as sweet as you think and he is representing this town so well! 🙂
~Maggie~ says
My fingers are crossed for queso….OMG I nearly died. I love that.
Paige says
So much goodness in one post. So funny!
Liz F. says
Warsaw was so charming it reminded me a bit of Star's Hollow (from Gilmore Girls). I almost began stress eating during Emily's date–it was so stressful watching her implode (I could have totally used the cheese platter from the group date). familyoffoley.wordpress.com
Anonymous says
Liz…..that's exactly how I refer to Warsaw. I've lived here for 6 years and it reminds me of Stars Hollow, especially with the many little festivals. I don't know Ben, but I know his mama…and she is wonderful.
Narci says
Lol-ing at the queso!!! So funny, girl!!
Stephanie B. says
Love reading all of your Bachelor re-caps, but especially Ben's season. I love 5 minutes from Warsaw and it really is as great as it seems. I think you should round up Erika, Shay, and Andrea to move here because I love all of your blogs.
Sunnysb99 says
You are hysterical! I'm loving the look of the loose white T, any brand suggestions?
Susir says
I have been looking forward to your recap all week. However I thought you would mention that there finally was a straddle run. Well not so much run but she did jump and straddle. I think it was jojo but I can't remember for sure.
Stacie Bellam says
My fiancé lives in Warsaw! 🙂 Winona Lake really is that stinking cute! Winona lake is where all the lake scenes were at, it's so fun to go there in the summer. It's about 25 minutes from where I live. Downtown Warsaw is charming also, although the rest of Warsaw isn't super picturesque. 😉
Ashley says
Stacie–I grew up in Huntington, and we were in Warsaw for things randomly…all I could think was "This isn't all of Warsaw"…because you're totally right–Winona Lake, amazing. Downtown Warsaw, adorable. The rest of Warsaw…like every other small town in Indiana….not nearly as nice 🙂
Katie Wells says
After Emily's….confessions…I couldn't wait to see what you'd write!!! Mama Higgins was NOT happy! I'm gonna go ahead and make my prediction: Becca as the next Bachelorette!!! Third times a charm, right?!
P.s. I think I speak for ALL PTMT fans…you should host a finale party!!! Who knows, Chris Harrison might show up!
Jennifer Richards says
I just LOVE your Bachelor recaps! You say what we're all thinking but can't find the funniest words!
Doreen Appiah says
Hilarious recap! I was cracking up at "#McCouple." I also think Ben set Emily up. He knew she'd dig her own grave meeting his parents so it'd be easy for him to get rid of her. It's funny to see the maturity level between the girls. Caila is only 1 year older than Emily but is way more mature. Can't wait till the women tell all!
kelly says
I loved "McCouple" too!
Megan says
I wondered if they promised Becca, the bachelorette, if she went in Ben's season. And the twins are GOLD for bachelor in paradise. I mean GOLD!!
Mandy Lee says
I completely agree with all of this!!! ☝️
Kate L. says
Your recaps get better and better each week. They're one of the reasons I keep watching the Bachelor. Jojo was warming up her jump and straddle this week, though. When she got out of her car in Chicago and straddled him, I immediately thought, "I wonder what Sheaffer would rate that one?" HAHA
SarahN says
I always love your recaps….but wait….did you not mention Emily's fringe must-have scarf from blog year's past? 🙂 hahaha
KRISTIN TATE says
I know we've never met but I LOVE YOU!! You crack me up! This is true talent. #forrealthough
Anonymous says
Agree 100%
I so wanna have a drink with Schaeffer!
Debbie Dankelson says
Same! You must host a "Party with Schaeffer" gathering. My friends and I would road trip from SW Missouri!!
midwestmom says
Yes JoJo did the straddle and I was thinking of this recap when I was watching! Also Emily is wearing the exact scarf from ptmt! She should have got to stay for that adorable outfit alone.
The Savage's says
I really thought you might say something about Ben's mom wearing the new MUST HAVE shirt! She was, right??
Erin says
I think I might love your recaps more than watching the show itself. You might need to set up a Bachelor live chat!
Erin says
I feel like there should be tshirts made with Arie's law on them. Love your recaps!!
Rachel S says
That scarf Emily is wearing on her date… is it not the Must Have fringe scarf? Sure looks like it!
Leslie says
Ummm do you think you could like start a petition to have Tim Tebow ask Becca out?! They would be the sweetest together! Lol
Karla says
They would be a darling couple.
Emily says
I'm from Warsaw, and LOVE it here. It actually is the Orthopedic Capital of the World-and I work for one of the major companies (the Z hotel that was mentioned in the episode is part of our campus, it's where we have surgeons and reps stay!). It really is a lovely town!
Rachel Werts says
Your recaps are the best thing ever
http://Www.wertsfamilychronicles.blogspot.com
Rachel Werts says
Your recaps are the best thing ever!
http://www.wertsfamilychronicles.com
Andrea says
I just laughed out loud about 10 times reading your recap! Perfect!
Blondie says
"#letspouroneoutfordesiresbrother"
BAHAHAHA!
Kelli says
I'm like you! Ready to see some full mounts next week on the hometown dates! I loved hearing your bachelor rule book! Hilarious.
http://modgehodgepodge.blogspot.com/2016/02/bachelor-ben-in-indiana.html
Angela Pino says
I love your Bachelor Rules. I vote for a whole post dedicated to those!
Jessie Tolton says
Girl….you are funny. Like seriously funny. #McCouple ..Lol You come up with the best stuff!!!
Rachel says
I'm surprised you didn't comment on Ben's horrible collar underneath his suit jacket at the rose ceremony. It's like it was cut off. Or is that in style now? Let's hope not.
Claire Ritchie says
"Cue Lauren's ovaries exploding in 3…..2…..1……."
Your best Bachelor recap yet! Spot-on in your opinions, with humor to boot… Hilarious 🙂
And love your common-sense but adorable fashion. Thanks!!
Carl and Lindsey says
I live in Warsaw too and loved this episode of Bachelor! When my husband and I got married we lived in a little cottage on Winona Lake, across the lake from Ben. The http://www.villageatwinona.com is so cute, we love going down there in the summer but the really the rest of Warsaw is just a small Indiana town.
Kristi Mitchell says
You write the best recaps!
Rachel says
#McCouple and Twin Enterprises. You have me CRYLAUGHING over here!! I literally look forward to these recaps all week!
#thestuffshaeffercomesupwith
-Rachel at thefashionistahousewife.blogspot.com
Christi Heeey says
First of all, your recaps are absolutely delightful. I am a bachelor nut in every sense of the word. I have watched each episode of this season at least four or five times. It gets lonely with the kids at school, so Ben talks to me as I do all of the mundane tasks of the day.
With that being said, I usually pick up on new details each time I watch an episode. Did anybody else hear when Ben was being interviewed after they first got to the bar in Warsaw, that he said, "Jubilee gets to see the real me." Oopsie. Editing mishap deluxe! He is also wearing different clothes in the interview, but the shot of him in the same spot just prior to this one, he was wearing the same clothes, and talking about Lauren.
Yes, I'm really good at those pictures that you have to figure out the itsy bitsy differences between the two.
Unknown says
I am new to your blog… and I am here to tell you that you brighten my day. Thanks for all of the hard work it takes to do what you do. You are funny, and real and I think you should be on TV.
Sheaffer {Pinterest Told Me To} says
Well, YOU brightened my day!!!!! Thanks for reading and for the sweet words!!!! xoxo, Sheaffer 🙂