Sheaffer Told Me To

Shopping with Sheaffer: OLD NAVY Edition!

By 1,042 Comments

So today is the 2nd installment in the Reader’s Choice series, and you ladies picked Old Navy!
One thing I learned while writing this post and after reading lots of your comments is the fact that they offer regular, tall, and petite in almost all of their choices!  They also offer lots of amazing plus size and maternity options.   Way to go Old Navy for catering to EVERY woman!!!! 

And guess what?!?
When Old Navy heard that all of you girls picked them they were so excited that they came on board to sponsor the post and offered to give away TWO $250 gift cards!  WOOHOO!
Thank you Old Navy!
Make sure you all enter at the bottom of the post!

(I know it’s Tuesday, and I don’t normally post on Tuesdays….
but I’m posting today because of the OLD NAVY SALE happening right now!  Several things are on sale through midnight tonight, and I didn’t want you ladies to miss the sale prices!)
UPDATE:  OLD NAVY EXTENDED THEIR SALE THROUGH WEDNESDAY!
WAHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
Use the code”HOORAY” for 30% off!
(fyi:  If an item is an everyday steal, hot deal, or today only deal….
the price advertised is what you get!
Those items are great prices, but not an additional 20% off.) 
SCORE! 
Both of these deals end today, so TAKE ADVANTAGE GIRLS!!!!  You’ve got nothing to lose!
If you shop today, you are going to be get A LOT OF AMAZING items for a little bit of $.
Girl Math states to STOCK UP. 😉

And you know, I’m not sure why, but until this post I hadn’t shopped at Old Navy in forever.
Like it had probably been at least 2 years.
BUT THAT HAS ALL CHANGED MY FRIENDS.
After the experience I had shopping both in store and online, Old Navy will definitely become one of the sites I check on a regular basis!  I got some FANTASTIC things that I am soooo excited about!


I found LOTS that I liked A LOT , and I found a couple of things that I absolutely LOVE.
Like OBSESSED WITH LOVE.

As most of you know, while shopping online last week, I put together the following outfit (all pieces from Old Navy):  boyfriend skinny jeans HERE / black tweed puffer vest HERE
plaid shirt HERE / cognac booties HERE

 I liked the items just fine online (and I thought the above collage was seriously cute), but I still wasn’t convinced that I was going to love the items.
SHAME. ON. ME.
Because I AM TOTALLY CRAZY about the flannel and the tweed vest.
Like CERTIFIABLE.
CRAZY TOWN.
Slap my mama and call me Penelope.
I have no idea what that even means.
See? 
CUH-RAZY.

Wanna see what all the fuss is about?
Prepare yourself.
Because you’re about to go crazy too.
…………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………..
ARE YOU DYING AT THE CUTENESS?!?
#somebodygetthepaddles
#clear
(that one was for you Cassie!)
 black tweed puffer vest HERE / plaid shirt HERE 
abalone earrings HERE, sanibel pendant HERE, similar jeans (just darker wash) HERE, and click HERE for a similar pair of jeans from Old Navy / Pillar Box red Hunter boots HERE

I couldn’t love the outfit more if I wanted to.
In fact, let’s take another moment to admire the flannel and the puffer.
Yes.
LOVE.
Well played Old Navy, well played.

GIRLS.  
I cannot say enough about THIS FLANNEL.
I’m sooooooooooo glad you chose Old Navy for this Reader’s Choice, or I never would have found it!
I have no doubt that it’s going to be one of my fall and winter favorites!
I recommend sizing up a size in this shirt.  For size reference, I’m wearing a medium.
 (That’s good news for some of you because this exact shirt is only available in L, XL, and XXL.  So, if you’re typically a medium, the large should work on you.)


And the puffer?
OH EM GEEEEEEEE at THE PUFFER. 
For size reference, I’m wearing a small, but the small looks too tight if I try to button and zip it up.
So, keep that in mind when ordering.  I’m thinking a medium would have been fine on me too.
(Again, the black tweed puffer is sold out of xs, small, and medium….l, xl, and xxl still available.)
LOOK AT THE TWEED!
CHECK OUT THAT COLLAR!
I don’t know know if I mentioned it already…
but I’M DYING OVER HERE!
 Click HERE for the black tweed puffer.

Okay….so if you are soooooooo sad because you are an x-small, small, or medium girl, but you REALLY the flannel…..
The same flannel also comes in these 2 colors (5 colors total).  I’m thinking about getting the blue one on the right too!  It’s so bright and fun!
Click HERE to see all 5 colors. 
After the 30% off was applied, the blue shirt I bought was $17.46!!

And if you are silently crying right now because YOU HAVE TO HAVE A PUFFER DANGIT and OH THE HUMANITY BECAUSE THEY ARE ALREADY OUT OF YOUR SIZE, I do believe I have more good news for you.
Yes, the tweed puffer has limited sizing available.
But THIS puffer is fully stocked and is an amazing deal!
I’m quite sure they won’t last long, so you better shake a stick at it (that one’s for you dad).  🙂
Click HERE for this quilted puffer (also available in a military green color).
All 3 of these look great!
The collar isn’t quite as big as the collar on the tweed vest, but it still has good structure to it, and I love the pockets and the quilted look!
Cute over stripes, cute over a flannel, cute over a solid tee!
CUTE! CUTE! CUTE!

And click HERE for other vest options!
In addition to the SUPER SUPER cute options below (love the collars!) they also have some plus-size and maternity vests to offer!
Click HERE for the long sleeved jacket options.  Look how the navy one on the left has the great contrasting piping on its edge!



All right, take a minute to revive yourself from the cuteness overload and pull yourself together.
Now it’s time for you to come along on my shopping trip to Old Navy!

First up, let’s talk about their PIXIE PANTS!
Have you heard about these?
A couple of you girls e-mailed me telling me I had  to try them because they were fabulous, and you were right!
They come in around  5,326 colors and patterns (okay, I might be exaggerating a wee bit), and I feel like all of us could use one or two pairs of these in our closets!
AND LET ME SAY…TODAY IS THE DAY TO BUY THEM!
THEY ARE $25 TODAY!!!!  TWENTY FIVE DOLLARS!  FOR A PAIR OF PANTS!
I’m getting the graphic black and white pair (a great way to try out the printed pant trend without spending a lot of money), and I think I might go ahead and get the plain black pair too.
Now listen.
I recommend sizing up in these pants for a comfortable and flattering fit.
I normally wear size 4 in most brands, size 2 in LOFT, but the Pixie pants fit me best in a size 6.
If you have these pants, please leave a comment on if you had to size up too!
(Several ladies have already left comments saying that they didn’t size up.  But then somebody else left a comment saying that she and her daughter both had to size up. Sorry to confuse things!)
Click HERE for Pixie pants.
They have the perfect amount of stretch in them!
They come in regular, petite, and tall…so make sure you order accordingly!  Mine are “regular”.
You are going to see these pants in all of the above colors throughout the post today, but I just wanted to introduce them to you first!

Okay…let’s get on to some outfits!

Click HERE for the graphic pixie pants.
Click HERE for the clementine top.   
(For size reference, I was wearing a small, but I think I needed a medium, they just didn’t have one.)
scarf not found online
***Click HERE for the mixed media denim jacket.*** 
For size reference, I was wearing a small in the jacket.
Here’s a close up of the jacket:
mixed media denim jacket HERE – LOVE!
clementine top HERE
(sizes listed above)
Here’s a close up of the pants!  LOVE LOVE LOVE the fit and the regular length was perfect for me to pair with flats.  For size reference, I’m almost 5’4″.
Again, I’m recommending to just bite the bullet and order a size up!
 I decided to mix it up a bit and try the pants with a plain black top and some bright shoes too!
black top HERE
graphic pixie pants HERE
women’s orange suede moccasins HERE
The reviews are mixed on the moccasins, mainly because there seems to great variability in sizing.  I’m a 6-6 1/2, and the 6s were perfect on me.  They were very comfortable (actually felt more like house shoes than shoes), and the color was very vibrant!
They obviously remind me so much of my mandarin MK moccasins!
(Please excuse the dirty mirror.  I guess I’m going to have to start traveling with Windex and paper towels.  You think I’m kidding.)  😉
And because I love it so, I threw on the denim jacket again.
mixed media denim jacket HERE
Okay, so I finally took off the first pair of pixie pants, and I tried on the boyfriend skinny jeans.
I had ordered them for myself in a 4, but they were too big and slouchy for my taste.
So, I tried on the 2 in store and liked them so much better.
plaid infinity scarf HERE 
(I actually like the navy version even better!)
navy sweater HERE
boyfriend skinny jeans HERE (I’m wearing a 2, so I suggest sizing down.)
faux suede ankle booties HERE
These are a great low-heeled bootie!
 Here is an office appropriate outfit:
pixie pants HERE
grey patterned knit top HERE
signature necklace HERE (mine is the 16″ antique gold) / nude flats HERE
This is the same top as the orange one above that I’m wearing with the black and white graphic pixie pants, but now I’m wearing a medium.  I definitely like the medium on me better!
 And y’all.
You had to know that if there was a military jacket within 10,000 or so square feet I would find it and try it!  This one was sooooo cute!
I loved the longer length, and the ability to cinch it in at the waist was great!  I thought it was very flattering cinched in and zipped up.  And if you’re looking for a jacket that is long enough to cover your bootie…this one should do the trick!
canvas utility jacket HERE (also comes in a dark khaki color!)
(If you are interested in a utility jacket for your little guy, click HERE.)
 boyfriend skinny jeans HERE (I’m wearing a 2, so I suggest sizing down.)
faux suede ankle booties HERE
This next outfit is easy, casual, comfy, and looks put together with only 3 pieces!
flannel popover HERE (also comes in a great red that wasn’t in store!)
For size reference, I was wearing a small in the popover, but a medium would have been better.  It was a little snug across the chest.
THESE are the rockstar zip pocket super skinny jeans.  
I loved these jeans! They reminded me a lot of the Treasure and Bond moto jeans from Nordstrom, and the price is unbelievable!  I would again recommend sizing up in these.  I am wearing a 6 here.
After the 30% OFF was applied, these jeans were $26.80!
faux suede ankle booties HERE
 I thought this next outfit was fun too!
faux leather quilted jacket HERE
leopard v-neck HERE
boyfriend skinny jeans HERE
faux suede ankle booties HERE
This next outfit is so ME.
I’ve always admired camo jackets, but I’ve never wanted to fork over the $80 or more for one, because I just wasn’t sure how much I would wear it.
Well, NO MORE EXCUSES!
This one is $24.97 today and is fully stocked!!!!!!!  WHAT?  AWESOME!
Click HERE for the camo jacket.  Plus size option available HERE.
For size reference, I was wearing a small.
I bought this jacket this morning, and the 30% OFF code worked and I got this jacket for $17.48!!!!!
YIPEEEEEE!!!!!!!
Click HERE for the baseball sweater.   Plus size option available HERE.
For size reference, I was wearing a small.

faux suede ankle booties HERE
And now we have another office appropriate look with the khaki pixie pants!
khaki pixie pants HERE
chiffon printed blouse HERE
I was wearing a small, and I was wearing a tank under it because it’s very sheer!
signature necklace HERE (mine is the 16″ antique gold) / nude flats HERE
I thought you might want a close up of the length!  These are the regular length and I’m almost 5″4″.
They also come in tall and petite.
pixie pants HERE
I thought this next outfit was cute and fun!
khaki pixie pants HERE
 mixed media denim jacket HERE
Have you fallen in love with the jacket yet?!?!
baseball sweater HERE
Okay……so NOW have you fallen in love with the jacket!?!
Click HERE for the jacket.  🙂
And right before I left, I realized I needed to try on some of their active wear!
People say it’s awesome, so I had to see for myself.
I was so surprised by how much I loved the yoga pants on me!
Flattering and slimming, but not restrictive or too tight at all!
women’s slim cut boot cut yoga pants HERE-
After the 30% OFF was applied, these yoga pants were only $13.96!!!!!  I should have gotten 2 more colors!  (With free shipping, I guess I still can!)
I can’t find the striped hoodie online, but click HERE for several other color options! 
After 30% off, this hoodie is $16.05!
Oh wait!  A reader found the striped one HERE!  Thank you!

And because I just couldn’t help myself, some more favorites that I didn’t get a chance to try on, but that I am loving!!!!!

MUST HAVE shirt look-a-like HERE
red pea coat HERE
 caramel mid-rise skinny jeans HERE
oversized scarf HERE
 strappy ankle boots HERE 

 mustard cable knit sweater HERE


 
Such good stuff, right?!?
I’m telling you,
Old Navy surprised me in the best possible way!!!!!
I was super impressed for sure!  ESPECIALLY with all of their outerwear.
(And speaking of outerwear, if you haven’t purchased hoodies or jackets for your kids yet, they have great selection for both boys and girls from infancy on up!  At 20% OFF, now is the time to buy!)

Two big thank yous before you leave:
1)  Thank you to the readers for encouraging me to give Old Navy a try!
I’m so happy I did, and I will definitely continue to shop it in the future!
2)  Thank you to Old Navy for sponsoring this post and for the reader gift cards!






Enter the rafflecopter below!  There will be 2 winners!!!
xoxo,
Sheaffer 🙂

Filed Under: Fashion 1,042 Comments

You’ll Also Love

Shopping with Sheaffer: Target Edition!
Pinterest Told Jenni To!
Gateway Jeans

Comments

  3. Julie Mills says

    Thanks for all the suggestions! I'm thinking of ordering one of the flannels. And after your review of the pixie pants and the price, I think I may need a pair of those too!

    Reply

  4. Mix and Match Mama says

    Listen! I loved everything! You look so good in those Pixie Pants and cute jackets, but I think those flannel shirts and puffers are my very favorite! Love, love, loved all of it!!

    Reply

  6. Tab & Erika says

    That first outfit is so cute!!! It looks so much cuter on you than the pics online. Old Navy should give you a call!! 🙂

    Reply

  7. Meagan @ The Clanahan Fam says

    So IN LOVE with the tweed puffer. When I saw it online last week I was lamenting to a friend that they didn't have my size. Then shockingly, it arrived in the mail yesterday. Ummm, I guess I've been on such a fall shopping streak that I totally forgot I had already ordered it? I'm starting to LOSE MY MIND! But at least I'm going crazy in a super cute vest.

    Reply

  8. Jana Domyslawski says

    Oh goodness, I sure did see some goodies I want to purchase…camo jacket, the jean hoodie….. I have 2 pair of pixie pants (khaki and red) and I LOVE them!!!

    Reply

  10. Kim Pintar says

    I ordered last week and last night… The plaid scarf, military vest, jean jacket and plaid shirt! I also ordered a camo shirt and buffalo check dress 🙂 yeah Old Navy!!

    Reply

  11. Brianne Doerger says

    I feel like I should be mildly embarrassed when I already own several of the items you featured. Hee. This was a great post! I really appreciate it when you show us awesome ways to style less expensive pieces.

    Reply

  13. Kathy Olson says

    You looked so cute in everything. I esp. liked the leopard v-neck. I would probably spend the $250 on kid jackets and Christmas shopping:)

    Reply

  15. Camille Columbia says

    i LOOOOOVE the faux suede booties + boyfriend jeans combo. one of my favorite things you've ever posted. but ohmygosh sheaffer don't go barefoot in the dressing room!! eeeeeeeeeeeeebiejeebies! 😀 😀 loving this series where you go to other stores!

    Reply

  21. The Brasfields says

    I am loving ON this fall! I own the brown boots in your last image, the black tweed jacket and the flannel. I am thinking about that denim jacket and pants now thanks to this post!

    Reply

  22. Anonymous says

    I love the outfits you've put together!! I shop at Old Navy often but don't always know what goes together, so thanks for some great inspiration (as always)!!
    Shannon in PA

    Reply

  23. Emily says

    The pixie pants are so cute! I could definitely wear those to teach in 🙂 I haven't been to old navy is so long, thanks for the great finds!

    Reply

  25. DAVID+VICTORIA says

    I ordered the flannel buffalo check shirt in navy yesterday! Did you know that all Gap brands are having FREE two day shipping through today?? It's posted at the top of each website and you just click to redeem! 🙂 great post!!

    Reply

  31. Eileen says

    I love Old Navy. It's the store I shop at the most for my clothes (and a lot of my children's clothes!). Thanks for all the great outfit ideas. I can't wait to go shopping (again!).

    Reply

  40. Laura says

    Ahhh I think I posted… But then I had to re-log into google and who knows what happened!

    Thanks for highlighting Old Navy! I have a love/hate for this clothes. Sometimes my clothes from there shrink which makes me super unhappy but I love their prices and have other pieces that u just adore!

    Reply

  41. SarahN says

    Thank you for posting about Old Navy! Those of us with tight budgets shop there often and it's nice to know our Sheaffer can find cute outfits there too! 🙂 I NEED that plaid shirt!!!!!

    Reply

  42. Annie says

    Thanks for featuring Old Navy! I ordered the tweed vest and flannel after seeing it FB. LOVE! I may need that mixed media jacket…

    Reply

  43. Laura says

    Just a tip – use code "HOORAY" for 30% off through the end of the day today (Tuesday) – I got this code in an email from Old Navy!

    Reply

  56. Rachel says

    🙂 Loved this post! I ordered the flannel shirt when it first came out and the tweed vest last week. I love that so many items come in tall sizes! I am 5'9", so usually right between a small and medium for length. Small tall is perfect — no more tops that are too loose yet the right length! 🙂

    Reply

  65. Julie Connelly says

    I would like one of each please!! 🙂 I am very impressed with Old Navy right now. Like you, I haven't shopped there in years…looks like I will be shopping there today!!! One question…what size were you wearing in the ankle booties?????

    Reply

  70. Melodie says

    I sometimes don't have much luck shopping at old navy for myself. But I do love those plaid shirts and their workout gear. I can always my kiddos things there.

    Reply

  72. Natalie Zambreski says

    I HAVE to have it ALL! I just ordered the puffer vest online, and I'm going to go to Old Navy on my lunch break today to try on the mixed media jacket and the pixie pants! I love that so many of these are casual enough for every day but can also be worn to work. LOVE LOVE EVERYTHING!

    Reply

  82. The Queen Family says

    I've been shopping at old navy the last two years or so pretty regularly after many years of never really going there. Their stuff has gotten sooo cute! I didn't buy anything today after your post because I was there this weekend and spent way too much money 😉 loved your post!

    Reply

  83. This Gingers Journey says

    THAT jacket!!! I saw it in the store this weekend and they didn't have any size close to mine…. You just confirmed that I NEED it! Ordered! Thanks 🙂 All your outfits are so cute!!! (but then again they always are!) You rock

    Reply

  86. Anonymous says

    Seeing the pixie pants has me excited to try them. I have considered in the past, but sizing throws me off sometimes. I pretty consistently need whatever size you order in things, so your posts are always very helpful to me! We have similar builds, except I'm an inch shorter 😉

    Reply

  96. Denise K says

    Thank you!!! I love everything. I had seen the infinity scarf but really didn't wan to pay shipping for it, then I got your email about 30% and 2 day free shipping. I was like Woo Hoo,

    Reply

  104. Peggy Bowes says

    So bummed! I tried to order that plaid infinity scarf in the green, but it sold out! Now I may have to drive an hour to the store… I do have the striped activewear hoodie you showed in the navy blue, and I love it! It's so soft and comfortable, and the navy is dark enough to pass off as black.

    Reply

  105. beaner says

    Love the pixie pants, I bought the tall as I am 5'10 but I didn't find I had to size up. I normally order a size 6 from old navy and that is what I needed in the pixie pant. I have the puffer jacket (bought it last year) and love it! I have the plaid shirt on the right in your graphic but love the blue!! Old navy is great for many things!!

    Reply

  109. Anonymous says

    I bought the navy pixie pants a week or so ago and I love them! They are so comfy! Can't wait to try the black and white ones.

    Reply

  118. Becky Bullock says

    So happy I saw your fb post about the vest before my size sold out. Love it & love your blog! My closet thanks you 🙂

    Reply

  129. teleana says

    I love it all, thats why i need to win the gift card!! I have the suede booties from last year and I love them. wear them all the time.

    Reply

  130. jessica says

    Great giveaway! Loving so many of your recommendations today. I have the tweed best and had recommended it to many friends. So super cute

    Reply

  131. Amber Arnold says

    Love Old Navy and shop there all the time. Just got a couple of great flannels and a clearance dress there for less than $10.

    Reply

  133. Kelsey Jessee says

    Love the pixie pants! And I also just bought the same red and blue flannel you featured. Can't wait to pair it with some boyfriend jeans!!! Might need to grab a puffer vest too!! My shopping list is growing and growing thanks to you Shaeffer!!!!

    Reply

  143. Erica Gammon says

    Awesome post!!!! Loved every second…couldn't wait to scroll down to see what was next! I'm dying over that camo jacket! Ordering it NoW!!!!

    Reply

  144. Dana Vissage says

    I love Old Navy and probably 75% of my closet is ON!! I did a post last week about my leopard favorites and they were items from there! Check it out! I am ordering that flannel shirt NOW!! Thanks Shaeffer!!

    Reply

  146. Laura Burke says

    Definitely going to try to Pixie pants – I realized with the change in seasons that I am too small for the majority of my work pants!

    Reply

  152. Rachel Caruso says

    That second puffer vest is coming home with me!! unfortunately the pixie pants do not look good on me.. I've tried. but they look GREAT on you!!

    Reply

  153. Jamie says

    love old navy yoga pants…i lived in the maternity ones while i was pregnant. also, would love to see you do a blog shopping at the limited 🙂

    Reply

  156. Anonymous says

    I got the flannel shirt & pixie pants. Ordered the puffer vest but it was too small so its going back. Thanks for sharing the other vests. I think the smaller collar would be nice too.

    Reply

  159. Stacey Haugen says

    I ordered the black floppy hat from there, which has turned out to be so much cuter than I thought. They have really stepped it up over the past few years.

    Reply

  166. Kelsey O'Brien says

    Love me some Old Navy! I haven't had a chance to check them out this season but I think I shall be taking a trip there!

    Reply

  167. Keri Brown says

    Thank you so much for shopping Old Navy!! I have several of the pixie pants and love them! I bought the quilted vests in cream and coral last year and they are great! Please do more posts at Old Navy! Thank you!!

    Reply

  170. Natasha H says

    Love Old Navy these last few years!! I ordered pixie pants in a size 4 and regular length (I'm 5'3) but probably will exchange for a petite length since I felt the knee area didn't fit me quite right. Been so impressed with all their accessories and longer style tunic tops. Fab job Old Navy and to Sheaffer for all her fun commentary :):)

    Reply

  181. April Parrish says

    Lots of great stuff from Old Navy. I have this tweed vest, but wish that the neck wasn't so bulky. I see you have your hair up…would you be able to wear it down with this vest??? When I wear my hair down with it's just uncomfortable! I l love how you paired the plaid with this vest…looks great on you!!!
    Have a great day! 🙂

    Reply

  183. Tessa Ernst says

    Love the puffer vest! Way more wallet friendly than the one I was stalking at Gap. I love this series BTW. Awesome idea and great affordable stores so far. Totally appreciated!

    Reply

  184. Amanda Brezgel says

    Love this Shopping with Schaefer edition! So many great choices and great sale too! Thanks for finding that great plaid! I love it and my fiance loves it 🙂

    Reply

  185. Anna says

    I haven't ventured to Old Navy yet this season but from the looks of your post, I need to run! Thanks for the cute outfit ideas!

    Reply

  194. Emmy says

    I saw that coupon code yesterday and I was all over that site since I've been stalking their vests! I went with the white quilted one you posted above, and I also threw this plaid boyfriend flannel shirt (in the buffalo blue: http://oldnavy.gap.com/browse/product.do?pid=122355032&vid=1&locale=en_US&kwid=1&sem=false&sdReferer=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2Furl%3Fsa%3Dt%26rct%3Dj%26q%3D%26esrc%3Ds%26source%3Dweb%26cd%3D1%26ved%3D0CCAQFjAA%26url%3Dhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.oldnavy.com%252Fproducts%252Fwomens-plaid-flannel-boyfriend-shirts-P122355.jsp%26ei%3DrjcYVI6NIuThsATdwIL4CQ%26usg%3DAFQjCNEw_ITUMUq-0xvsL-_w2B52A73x1g%26sig2%3Dp4HZmOeevSvAO2mJ5g9gXQ%26bvm%3Dbv.75097201%2Cd.cWc) in my cart while I was at it because…30% off AND free shipping? Be still my heart. And now, thanks to your post, I'm on their checking out the pixie pants….

    Reply

  196. nichole says

    I have found some very cute jeans at Old Navy. I'm in the process of losing weight and needed some new jeans while I'm sizing down and didn't want to spend a fortune for jeans I'll only wear for a season. I LOVE my Old Navy jeans.

    Reply

  197. the pink prep says

    I mix in ON with everything… in fact, today, I'm wearing a colbalt blue silk tank from ON, a JCrew black lace skirt, Belk black leather jacket and grey ON ballet flats. They really are getting more classic with their designs! I got the tweed vest (just waiting to wear it) and an adorable Camo quilted vest from the girl's dept (size XXL is a girls 16 or a woman's 4/6)
    hoping for a restock on the red plaid shirt…
    and don't get me started on the pixies… they are AWESOME! I have them in poppy orange, a pink print, white and grey! Totally work/out versatile!

    Reply

  199. Michelle Ragsdale says

    I bought the plaid shirt last week…loving it!! Thank goodness I had a scheduled trip to the mall today ;)…going to check out the mixed media jacket and the pixie pants..love your blog!

    Reply

    • Sarah Yeatman says

      I love the plaid shirts you posted especially the blue ones and I loved how you showed all the pixie pant options they look great on you!

      Reply

  202. Kelly Wilson says

    I am a big fan of Old Navy, super cute clothes at great prices! I especially love them for kids clothes as well, their jeans always fit my kids the best. Thank you for the awesome giveaway!

    Reply

  203. Terrie Mathison says

    LOVED a lot of these!! Thanks Old Navy for coming on board too! I'll be shopping there today on my way home.
    I wanted to say I got my husband a military jacket from Old Navy in the Spring and he gets complements on it ALL THE TIME! I mean like other men complement him on his jacket! Do men do that? It's crazy how often it happens too. I will add it's hard to wear my military jacket when he is wearing his. I'm not a matchy married couple type.
    Thanks for the great posts, as always!

    Reply

  204. Kim says

    I'm thrilled at the possibility of winning some money to spend at Old Navy. I purchased the pixie pants and the black puffer vest. Both should be fun additions to my closet.

    Reply

  209. Erin @ Crafts and Sutch says

    Old Navy is one of my staples! I shop there all the time for myself and my kiddos. I love their Sweetheart jeans. They have a great fit for girls with more than a little tush and they are super affordable. Fantastic round up!

    Reply

  215. Casey Ferri says

    I went way out of my way to an Old Navy after work last week specifically trying to find the plaid shirt – and it was worth it because I got the last XS they had!! Also bought the navy quilted vest from the girls' dept in an XL – fits basically the same as women's XS.

    Reply

  220. Susan Maliff says

    I hadn't shopped at Old Navy in a couple of years, however, last winter stopped into Old Navy while shopping at a mall in the area and ended up purchasing a winter MILITARY JACKET. (1 of 3 in my obsession/collection of military jackets…thanks to PTMT)! Since that time I have found many treasures at Old Navy…most recently pixie pants!!!

    Reply

  228. Jennifer @ Dimples and Tangles says

    I've been ordering often from ON online now. They offer Talls, which I love and need for long sleeve shirts. I always order 2 if I'm not sure on a size. I'm sure the return people in the stores hate me…

    Reply

  229. Anonymous says

    I almost ordered a vest yesterday from somewhere else that was quite a bit more expensive than these…you have totally sold me on the Old Navy vests!

    Reply

  230. Jenna Lathrop says

    I love the red hunters with those jeans and flannel. I had to order the Robbie Red Pixie Pants after reading this!

    Reply

  231. Melissa says

    I just bought a couple sweaters and a couple scarves yesterday! I'm also waiting for the tweed puffer vest to arrive from a previous order.

    Reply

  236. Wendy says

    The first outfit you tried on is one of my most very favorite on you (plaid shirt and puffer vest). You look adorable and gorgeous! I bought the blue plaid shirt and the quilted olive vest.

    Reply

  237. Sarah Goldsberry says

    Love this post! We shop Old Navy a lot, so it was fun to see what outfits could be put together with the items they have in stores now. I LOVE the yoga pants!!

    Reply

  241. Jessica Davidson says

    Great post! Love Old Navy and loved your picks! I feel I need to head to ON and try on the boyfriend jeans and the zipper jeans!!!

    Reply

  245. Kim Kauffman says

    I have to say I'm shocked at how much I like what you found! I have NOT had good luck with Old Navy in the past. I did order that flannel and the puffer last week after you posted on FB and they are coming this week! Now I'm tempted by the gray suede booties. I have been waiting to get the cognac pair at Nordstrom, but this might be a good option for my first pair! Think I'll have to run to the store today 🙂

    Reply

  249. hannah White says

    Love old Navy! They have a lot of great circle skirts right now too! Loving the plaid shirts and pixie pants! Glad you shopped Old Navy! Very helpful!

    Reply

  250. Melia Chitwood says

    I just ordered! I got the flannel shirt, tweed vest, denim jacket and a couple other things I already had sitting in my cart. Crossing my fingers on the sizing!

    Reply

  252. Amy says

    Thanks for posting the work outfits! Love to see office options. I am hoping Old Navy will honor the 30% off in store. If not, I'll try on in the store and buy online tonight. Thanks again, your blog is so fun to read!!

    Reply

  254. Jill Moore says

    I just ordered the black tweed vest last week- after seeing that you ordered it! I am thrilled I got a medium before they sold out! Old Navy is one of my favorites- not just for me but for me two little girls!

    Reply

  256. Anonymous says

    I'm typically not an old navy shopper either, but there are several things you highlighted that I like! Great job 🙂

    Reply

  258. Darcy says

    Thanks for this post – I'm headed to buy a puffer! I don't buy a ton from Old Navy, but I do like their dresses for wearing at work. They have a great selection of dresses with sleeves, and I like that they have extended sizes.

    Reply

  261. Kelli says

    The printed compression capris are awesome! Very flattering and reminds me of much more expensive brands. Fun patterns and comes in petite and tall too.

    Reply

  262. Kristen says

    I love Old Navy but I am usually looking there for my teenagers – no so much for myself. I appreciate that you showed us some great office-appropriate outfits as well as so much cute weekend wear! Great job, Sheaffer! I really enjoyed this post!

    Reply

  264. Laura Holland says

    Love this post! I have already found many of your recommended 'Fall staples' at Old Navy within the last few weeks, including the twill puffer vest and the cargo jacket, so thank you for showing some Old Navy love!

    Reply

  266. gotjack28 says

    I was eyeing the military jacket a few weeks ago when I was in there. I passed on it then… but not this time! I also ordered the flannel shirt.

    Reply

  267. Anonymous says

    Love Old Navy! Just got that puffer vest and the cute plaid scarf! I also purchased a blue and white buffalo plaid shirt there last week….can't beat the pricing!!
    Thanks for a fun post!
    Jan Fisher

    Reply

  271. Goodbyebreadandcheese says

    I love Old Navy for play clothes for my 4 year old and I got an A-line black dress from there last week for $20. Perfect for work and church and it's so versatile I'll wear it a million different ways all fall and winter long!

    Reply

  274. Sara says

    Thanks for doing a more affordable option for once! I don't know how all of you spend so much at Nordstrom, so this is a welcome change.

    Reply

  275. Elizabeth Babicke says

    Shaeffer! I ordered the Buffalo Plaid swing dress. I saw it on another bloggers site and had to have it! I couldn't find it in stores so I'm not sure if it will fit but I think you would love it!

    Reply

  281. gotjack28 says

    I saw the military jackets a few weeks ago and passed on it… not this time! I got it in the camo AND the brown [green was sold out 🙁 ]I also got the flannel shirt 🙂

    Reply

  283. Skye says

    Old Navy is one of my favorite go to places. Their boyfriend skinny jeans are my favorite! I have the cropped ones, too that I wore all spring and summer!!!

    Reply

  284. Brandi C says

    I ordered the plaid shirt & the vest last week and love them both. So happy you've gave us some options from Old Navy! Thanks!

    Reply

  287. Sabrina says

    I love old navy!! It's one of my favorite stores. I loved all of your picks! I am going for the military green puffer and the mixed media denim jacket-I think I will like those! And the pixie pants-I tried them on a few weeks ago and holy comfort!!!! I loved loved loved this post!

    Reply

  288. Kristen says

    Love this post…I tend to only order things for everyone else in my family at old navy. It's fun to see things for me too!

    Reply

  289. Melissa Hill says

    I need to get myself on over to Old Navy!!! Oh–I entered my name wrong on instagram. My instagram name is jmh92599. I couldn't go back and correct it! Sorry!!

    Reply

  290. MaryAnn says

    I love Old Navy! And really love their pixie pants. I have not found that I need to size up though. And thanks for introducing the quilt vest – just ordered one for 30% off!

    Reply

  291. Karla says

    I bought that navy sweater with the scarf when I was in store last week! Love it for fall!!! I love their yoga wear as well! Awesome fit, and really holds up!

    Reply

  294. Jenna says

    I'd say your readership has quadrupled in size! You just say the word and EVERYTHING sells out online! WHAT?! I'm dying over that vest and am so bummed. So bummed. But shame on me. You linked to it a while back and I just glanced over it, thinking, I already own THREE puffer vests! I dont need one more! BUT I DO! I DO NEED ONE MORE!! Old Navy, please bring it back!

    Reply

  295. Kimberly W says

    I love Old Navy! I ordered the pixie pants, plaid shirt, a sweater and the booties. I noticed you showed a picture of the toffee booties, but you never said how you liked them in person. You loved the suede, but what did you think of the toffee? I was thinking of getting them too.

    Reply

  296. Amber Sanders says

    I LOVE that you are doing shopping with Schaefer at stores I actually shop at and are local to me! Thanks for all your style inspiration I truly love your blog!!

    Reply

  297. Renee Tribou says

    Love this post! I have been an Old Navy shopper for my entire adult life. As a working mom, I can always find great options for work and play. Just yesterday I placed an online order for their boot leg khakis and a great fleece hoodie for myself, as well as several pairs of pants for my first grader and preschooler.

    Reply

  302. Anonymous says

    Old Navy is awesome! Bought the first plaid shirt you showed and I too had to size up. I'm a sucker for plaid and vests right now but unfortunately the puffers dont work on me. As a slightly thicker girl, anything that adds bulk is not flattering on me at all. I have found the quilted vests work better for me. Thanks for all your suggestions, everything is so cute!

    Anna in Alabama

    Reply

  303. Shelly M says

    I LOVE that quilted vest! It doesn't seem as bulky which is great for a tall gal with big boobs! I'm ordering it right now! Love the flannel too. I'll get that too!! Thanks for all the great tips! You save me tons of time! 🙂

    Reply

  305. Kim says

    Great giveaway – hope to win! While I always love your blog posts and finds, I'm glad to see some other options of clothing besides Nordstrom and Loft! 🙂

    Reply

  306. Caitlin Williams says

    I ordered to plaid flannel! I am headed out this afternoon to try some pixie pants and may order those too. Thanks for posting! Old navy definitely fits this SLP2B's budget 🙂

    Reply

  311. violinista says

    Wow. They all look like awesome finds. I rarely go to Old Navy, too, just because anything I've gotten there usually falls apart fast. That being said, I can already think of a few items in my closet that I've used for years and years… so I guess it all depends. But for sure, I will be paying Old Navy a visit this week!! Thanks!

    Reply

  313. Erin says

    The Old Navy Visa card has super great rewards – I end up using my Old Navy card for a lot of big purchases at work, and then I score free clothing at Old Navy! Can't go wrong there!

    Reply

  315. sascha L says

    What a great post! Its easier to shop when you've put all the outFits together! I've never tried the pixie pants but now I want to.

    Reply

  316. Mindy Gray says

    Ok, I just want to point out some crucial info for online orders if you miss this amazing free two-day deal! It's usually only $50 minimum to get free shipping, and you can combine brands. If you can't find $50 between ON, Gap, and Banana, try harder!! Ha! But for real, that plaid scarf is coming home to me–thinking about the liquid leggings too. They're so on trend, but I'm thinking they could be hard to style. PTMT, go!

    Reply

  318. Joy says

    Love your blog posts and all the outfit inspiration! I do love Old Navy and it fits my budget perfectly so this is a great fit for me! 🙂 Looks like I will be shopping today!

    Reply

  323. Stephanie Confer says

    I am on the hunt for boyfriend jeans, I am going to have to check these out. And the flannel shirts are cute too!

    Reply

  324. Anonymous says

    I love Old Navy. I love their clothes, their prices and their styles. I can get a lot more for my money.
    I got the moccasins and the ankle strap booties. I really want the plaid shirt-will have to check my local store!
    DanielleF

    Reply

  331. Emily Hull says

    I haven't shopped at Old Navy in a long time! Thanks for highlighting these clothes-what a great sale! That vest is so cute!

    Reply

  333. Love2shop says

    Love the plaid shirt, so sad it's sold out in my size! Will keep looking for it to be restocked! Ordering the mixed media denim jacket now! 🙂

    Reply

  334. Kayla Roman says

    Yes!! I love Old Navy! I bought the puffer vest in khaki literally one day before you first posted about it on Facebook. But now I'm regretting getting it in khaki instead of black because the black looks so cute on you! Thanks for doing this post!

    Reply

  335. Anonymous says

    Love Old Navy, I have been knocking off a lot of your looks and others from pinterest with their clothes for a while! 🙂 – Leah S.

    Reply

  337. Kari Maddox says

    It's Tuesday, so I got 10% off for using my Old Navy card, plus the 30% off with the code AND the 2 day shipping! GO ME! I got the plaid flannel, a sweater and a jersey dress…to go with a tote I got from Nordstrom when you told me too. My husband said to stop listening to you 😉

    Reply

  338. Chelsea says

    I haven't ordered anything yet today, but I love so much of it! Agghhh! Would love to add the camo jacket, hoodie and tweed vest to my fall wardrobe at least!

    Reply

  339. Jenny says

    Old Navy has been hit & miss for me lately. I used to shop there very often but in the last year I haven't. The codes and free 2 day shipping are awesome so I am purchasing several items to try. Thanks for the post!!

    Reply

  340. Leah says

    Old Navy is one of my favorite stores! That quilted vest is going in my cart right now. Great post – I loved all your picks!!

    Reply

  341. Ashley says

    I bought the white shirt 3-4 weeks ago and was so excited to see it was one of your picks! I love it, now off to get the blue one!!

    Reply

  343. Carrie McKamie says

    Love the Old Navy post. They have so many great things at great prices. I would love to stock up on some fall fashion with a gift card. 🙂

    Reply

  347. TLP says

    Would love to win as I'm in between jobs right now! Summer is gone and would definitely wear the puffer vest in the New York cold :/

    Reply

  351. Jennifer says

    Just yesterday I placed an order on Old Navy and thought "Man, I wish Sheaffer would do a post on Old Navy" Now I need to go back and place a few more things in my order!

    Reply

  354. Kara D says

    I LOVE Old Navy! Some of these pieces are so cute! I'm 7 1/2 months pregnant, so I'm just lusting at some of them, but I can totally work those puffer vests!!! Going to check them out now… 🙂

    Reply

  356. delfamily says

    Old.navy is the BEST for long tanks…order a tall for a great longer tank….fabulous quality too, thicker and a quality feel.

    Reply

  360. Liz/ says

    Old Navy is one of my all time fav stores, I get pretty much everything I wear from ON and the GAP Outlet! I am off to order that tweed vest and of course more!!!

    Reply

  361. Christina Adamson says

    Just got the Military Jacket last night in the mail. LOVE!!! I am so excited to wear it… now if it would just start to get a little cooler here in Dallas, maybe I could wear it!

    Reply

  374. Michelle says

    I couldn't find the navy plaid scarf in my local On. Found the burgundy and love it! Pairing it up with an orange and grayish/brown color block sweater I found last year at JCP.
    My daughter loves the Sweetheart jean in a petite. She needs adult sizes, her shape is a changin' but not the length yet. These are so much better fitting on her than anything we have found anywhere else and at a price point I am comfortable with considering she will need a different size in 6 months.

    Reply

  377. Erica Ladwig says

    You did a fantastic job! I haven't shopped at Old Navy in a while either, but everything you picked is so cute! I'll have to try some of it out! 😉

    Reply

  380. katehaven says

    Ordered the houndstooth pixie pants and a flannel shirt. Plus a couple pairs of jeans to try.

    Old Navy does have great maternity options. Pretty much all of my workout gear is from Old Navy. And the jeans hold up really well.

    Reply

  382. Jackie Colegrove says

    Old Navy is my go to. Super cute and super affordable. I never feel guilty after shopping there bc I always get great deals. I have the puffer, pixie pants, booties, flannels (and sooo much more). I think the biggest thing with sizing is trying on. I was my normal size in the pixie but In some skinny jeans I have to size up.

    Reply

  387. clatk says

    Love ON! I ordered that vest (3 different times to get my size ?) and that flannel popover last week when you did the sneak peek on fb and insta! Love them!!

    Reply

  388. Maria says

    I'm so glad I read your post today! I've wanted to buy some black Pixie pants for work, but have been waiting for them to go on sale. Yay! Thanks for your post and what an awesome giveaway!

    Reply

  390. lamatejka says

    I need to quit reading your blog…I spend way too much money! 🙂 Not a big Old Navy fan, but ended up buying four things because they looked so cute on you!

    Reply

  395. rockinred says

    I was tempted by the flannel shirt with my last order, but didn't pull the trigger until seeing how CUTE it looks on you! By the way, check out the boyfriend cardigans – OMG, I am *obsessed* with them. I originally bought black & navy and just bought 3 more colors!!

    Reply

  396. Queen In Between says

    Yea for yoga pants that come in tall!! They are always perfect when I buy them but after one wash I end up looking like Urkel

    Reply

  403. A Beautiful Confidence says

    I need those pixie pants! I've been eyeing them for forever…but after seeing this post, I think it's a sign that I need to click order!

    Reply

  406. Leigh Ishee says

    Yesterday I bought the flannel shirt and the white puffer vest with the gold accents. I do plan on getting the black tweed puffer soon. Sooner if I win this gift certificate!! 😉

    Reply

  407. Stacey says

    Definitely ordering a vest and shirt today. You've found such great options! I have to say though, I checked out the Pixie pants in person and they are made for girls with NO booty. 🙂

    Reply

  409. Kimberly R. says

    I haven't been to old navy in a long time also, but your post convinced me to check it out again! And their prices are great for a college student like me:)

    Reply

  410. Lauren Baxt says

    I bought the plaid shirt and boyfriend skinny jeans last week and am bummed I didn't include the vest – love this, thank you!!

    Reply

  411. Charity says

    I would love to win this! I have recently lost weight, and am finding that none of my pants and fall clothes fit now. Fun problem to have but a pricey one!

    Reply

  413. Pamela says

    Sheaffer, you can make ANYTHING look cute!!! Seriously, you are so gifted at what you do. Thanks for all the helpful suggestions…now I'm off to place an Old Navy order!

    Reply

  415. Kristina says

    Love Old Navy and love your blog! I had just ordered the quilted puffer vest in white and the strappy ankle boots this morning before I read your post and now I want to go back and buy more! Thanks Sheaffer!

    Reply

  418. Anonymous says

    love, love, love Old navy!! A go-to for me and my two kids (ages 6 and 9). I like their khaki pants for my husband, as well.

    Reply

  419. Planned Style says

    Thanks for this fab giveaway. ON is one of my fave stores and if I win I'll get the puffy jackets and Pixie pants!

    Reply

  420. Kathryn says

    Seriously…these outfits are precious! Things I would never put together or would completely breeze by online…you have a talent for sure, Sheaffer!!

    Reply

  421. Brianne Bracco says

    Over the weekend I scored their awesome compression active pants with their BOGO deal and their new boot socks…cannot wait to wear those cuties underneath my Hunter boots 🙂

    Reply

  424. Loretta White says

    Love me some Old Navy! Great things to be had for everyone…so many size options! Cute stuff for the wee ones 🙂

    Reply

  425. Lendy Salazar says

    Old Navy is on the top of my list because they have awesome clothes for my little girl and clothes that looks good on me too!! Total win-win!!

    Reply

  432. PSUEmily says

    I love Old Navy! I have jeans from there that have held up better than some of my other more expensive jeans. I'm already adding several of your finds to my shopping bag! =)

    Reply

  433. V @ X-tremely V says

    I too had moved away from Old Navy for awhile, but they definitely have stepped up their game! Love all the items you featured! Heading over there online now!

    Reply

  443. Shari Sheranian says

    I've always been a fan of Old Navy but NOW! Thank thank you for the inspiration. I don't need to get dressed up at my office so I can find many inexpensive go to pieces here!

    Reply

  444. Hannah Lugibihl says

    I love Old Navy because they have a whole section of clothes for tall ladies! Not just pants — dresses, tops, workout clothes. Love it!

    Reply

  448. KT says

    Thanks so much for this!! I was on the fence about some of these items online (like the black & white popover), but you've convinced me to try them!

    Reply

  455. Tiffany {A Touch of Grace} says

    I shop for my daughter at Old Navy a lot, but haven't bought anything for myself in a while. I saw those pixie pants the other day and love them. And all the vests, oh my word it's vest heaven! Love them all! So fun!

    Reply

  459. Ansleighsmom says

    i already loved old navy but thanks for the new ideas on items u always style things so cute! I bought two shirts from their today and then just ordered those boots and the vest after seeing your pictures! u are the best would love the win the gift card to complete my fall/winter wardrobe!

    Reply

  463. agore says

    I was on my way to order that plaid flannel shirt but wouldn't ya know….sold out of my size. But there are so many other choices that you highlighted that I didn't notice at Old Navy yesterday. I'm going back!

    Reply

  467. Katy says

    LOVE OLD NAVY! Their jeans are great for when I'm trying to save up between designer jean purchases – or just for jeans that I can play around with my kids in. I think I'll be adding a flannel or two after seeing your post today!
    I bought the pixie bermuda shorts over the summer and while I loved the pixie material, I was not in love with the bermuda shorts…but maybe it's because I just don't love bermuda shorts.

    Reply

  468. Sailing Kat says

    I have never been in Old Navy (there isn't one near my house) but now I will definitely go online. Thank you for the great outfit ideas!!!! Love your blog!

    Reply

  469. Mattie says

    I bought the puffer vest and love it! I've been obsessively trying to find a red quilted vest, and I've looked everywhere. I've seen big puffy red vests, and berry-colored quilted lightweight vests, and I had seen the quilted Old Navy vest too but they didn't used to have red. My mom texted me this morning to tell me there was a red quilted ON vest in your post and I was so excited! I will get my red vest for Christmas after all. 🙂

    Reply

  471. Liz Bartemes says

    LOVE you in the flannel, puffer and Hunter combo! You are rocking that! Bummed the shirt is sold out online in my size but hoping if I stop by an actual store that I might get luck!

    Reply

  475. Danielle Hall says

    I just bought the black twill vest….in a tall. Which OMG! I can't believe they had it in a tall! Most vests look like belly shirts on me, and let me tell you, that is not a flattering look. I'm so glad I took a peek at the website. Fingers crossed that it looks as good on me as it does on you! (Also, I had a $20 GAP reward, so the vest cost me all of $8.50. I'm killin' it today!)

    Reply

  476. Danielle Hall says

    I just bought the black twill vest….in a tall. Which OMG! I can't believe they had it in a tall! Most vests look like belly shirts on me, and let me tell you, that is not a flattering look. I'm so glad I took a peek at the website. Fingers crossed that it looks as good on me as it does on you! (Also, I had a $20 GAP reward, so the vest cost me all of $8.50. I'm killin' it today!)

    Reply

  477. Margaret Morales says

    I love Old Navy but have never tried the boyfriend skinny jeans, I will definitely have to order a pair now! Thanks for the great post and giveaway!

    Reply

  478. Amber Gasswint says

    I love old navy. Right now I'm loving their vintage v-neck tees and their super soft knit shirts. Also I have a pair of jeans from 5 years ago that still look fabulous and I will be sad when they finally don't anymore.

    Reply

  483. Lyttle {LoveTheSullivans} says

    I love Old Navy! I'm so glad you're shopping there more often now and giving us item alerts. I already placed 3 orders last week with some of the items you highlighted today, but the 30% off, Free 2-day shipping combo, and your post pushed me to place order #4.

    Reply

  487. Anonymous says

    I have come to love Old Navy– always free shipping over $50 and free returns. And they run sales so often, that sometimes I order the exact same items a day or two after I place an order because everything is 25% or 30% off! Then I just send back my first shipment:)

    Reply

  490. Nerd Girl says

    Sigh. I was on a self imposed shopping ban, but I just pulled the trigger on the Quilted Vest. I've always liked the idea of vests, but never bought one for myself. Hoping this one is as fab on me as it is on you!

    Reply

  492. Kristin says

    Love this post and you look adorable in all the outfits. I always shop Old Navy for the kids but haven't looked for me in awhile, guess I should check back again. Hope to win!

    Reply

  494. Gina C. says

    I ordered the white/red flannel shirt and I love it! Although I'm typically a medium and I bought the medium-it fit great.

    Reply

  496. Kim says

    Old Navy has totally stepped up their game in the past couple of years. I know I can count on them for a couple great pieces each season. Glad you highlighted some of the items I already had in my cart!!!!!

    Reply

  498. The Fowlers says

    I love shopping at Old Navy! And, once you get used to paying their prices, it hard to ever shop anywhere else again!

    Reply

  500. Vicky says

    I really love Old Navy. They have some great clothes and always have wonderful discounts. Thanks for posting this….I added to my wardrobe based on your recommendations yet again!

    Reply

  503. Traci says

    I bought some of the suede loafers in store – you're right, they are SO comfortable and surprisingly soft. I also picked up a Classic Blazer in black, and a Boyfriend Cardigan in black. Gotta get those staples!

    Reply

  504. Kait Oglesby says

    YAY! Another Sheaffer giveaway! Love it. Old Navy has been hit or miss for me for a while, but I'll have to stop in and give it a look!

    Reply

  507. Sarah Johnson says

    I love Old Navy! I am always finding cute stuff for myself and my toddler girl. I already purchased some of the flannels you mentioned today and I love them. Nothing says Fall like a good flannel shirt 🙂

    Reply

  513. Morgan Barnett says

    I love almost all of Old Navy's stuff, but especially their outerwear and active wear! I have 4 different pair of work out pants and tons of their tanks… it's the best!

    Reply

  516. No Raisins on My Parade says

    I love that flannel. I also have been eying a similar tweed puffer vest from JCrew factory that is just too pricey at over $100, so I may have to give the Old Navy version a try instead!

    Reply

  520. Kimberly Dimmig says

    Old Navy is great! Needed a cute summer dress for an event at our local Art Museum and found a navy, crepe-like, long sundress. Very pretty and comfy too for $20! Old Navy has great shoes too! My daughter always takes advantage of the $1 flip flop Saturday-sale during the summer since we stock up for the year as she's a swimmer and wears them on the pool deck even in winter 🙂 Glad you highlighted Old Navy this week! Love the vest! Thanks!

    Reply

  529. Brent and Abigail says

    I am feeling so ahead of the game having ordered the tweed puffer a few weeks ago. The quality is great and I can't wait to wear it.

    Reply

  532. Pamela says

    Just finished my ON order. Hoping these will look cute together: gold sweater (planning to layer over demin shirt), with plaid scarf and cream vest. Hoping it will work with cords and boots! Thanks for showcasing these items…never would have found them and ordered without you!

    Reply

  534. Holly says

    I have been shopping a lot at Old Navy lately. I recently lost quite a bit of weight and needed lots of new clothes so really appreciate their great prices and sales! I ordered the brown tweed vest last week and received it yesterday-I love it! Think maybe I need the black too…I am 6' tall so also appreciate the fact that a lot of their things come in talls, not just pants but sweaters, tops and dresses too.

    Reply

  540. A Gal Named Al says

    Love Old Navy! Wear their khakis and pants for school and love their tops and sweaters. My son told me he wants me to buy the black motorcycle jacket, and I agree! 🙂

    Reply

  545. Stephanie says

    I went to Old Navy this weekend and got some maternity clothes (jeans, dress and top) all for under $10! Now I need to get that denim and military jacket, so cute!

    Reply

  551. Kathleen Hulbert says

    The plaid shirt is seriously too much. Old Navy is a staple for me for little boy clothes because their internal adjustments (on the waist) are perfect for my bean pole! Can't wait to check it out more for me.

    Reply

  555. tambrook04 says

    Love this post! I got the denim jacket & plaid flannel last week. Now I just bought the military jacket, mocassins and plaid infinity scarf! We just need some cooler weather so I can wear all this cute stuff!!

    Reply

  558. Becky A. says

    I am SO GLAD I read this post today! I have been stalking the green puffer and it has been sold out in tall for a few weeks. It's fully stocked today and a steal with the 30% plus free shipping! Thanks for an awesome and timely post!

    Reply

  559. Leslie says

    Love Old Navy! I am always able to find cute clothes there for me and my son. The holiday pj pants are a favorite of mine too as is the active wear! Thank you for some great outfit ideas!

    Reply

  563. Anonymous says

    I love Old Navy too! Really like their jeans – they fit! I know it's "fast fashion" but I do have some basics in my closet that have lasted a few years. Thanks for this post! – Gbea

    Reply

  566. Anonymous says

    I love me some old navy!! I love all your style choices but these options are more affordable for me! LOVE LOVE LOVE the puffer vests and the pixie pants!

    Rachel Stephens

    Reply

  567. Megan Patterson says

    I am glad to hear that you are different sizes at different stores. Sometimes I get discouraged having to buy different sizes. I love the puffer vest and plaid shirts! Thank you to for doing it so quickly so we can take advantage of the sales!

    Reply

  574. Steph says

    I am 7 months pregnant, but I'm sick of maternity clothes! So I would order the puffer vest to hide my post-baby tummy this winter. Oh and some boots!

    Reply

  575. laurasyes says

    I love old navy! The pixie pants are such a great fit . I did size up . I have found sometimes with old navy that their sizing isn't consistent and sometimes different colors are different sizes . Thank goodness for free returns !

    Reply

  581. Katie Fojtik says

    1) loved this post bc I LOVE old navy!
    2) immediately ordered the denim jacket and ended up getting it for $13 due to the 30% off and some old navy cash I didn't know I had on my account– talk about a score!!
    3) just thought you should know that I frequent your blog so much that when I begin typing the letters "pint" into my google bar it does not take me to "Pinterest" but directly to your blog 🙂 keep up the awesome work!

    Reply

  582. Renae says

    So surprised but in a good way. I'll order for my girls there but never look for myself… I will from now on. Thanks, will be buying many of your recommendations!!

    Reply

  583. Anonymous says

    I LOVE Old Navy and the entire Gap Family.. Especially for my boys. Thanks for featuring them! That mixed media jacket and the bright flannel are now on my list! -Jaclyn Rose

    Reply

  584. The Boutelle Family says

    This post is perfect timing! I just bought a bunch of fall clothes from Old Navy for our whole fam! I bought a pair of the distressed boyfriend jeans & they are so comfy! I already have a pair of rock star skinny jeans that I love – great jeans for under $30! I'm wearing the Plaid flannel boyfriend shirt in blue today & it's so comfortable!! If you size up, it is long enough to wear with leggings & looks super cute with brown boots!

    Reply

  587. Lindsay D. says

    Love this post! I haven't shopped at Old Navy or GAP in about 10 years, but lately I've been finding a few items that I really like. Now I wonder why I stopped shopping there! Thanks!

    Reply

  588. Lindsay B says

    Loving the Old Navy fall collection. Was just in there yesterday…having a baby this week, so will be stocking up in a month or so with all your cute outfit suggestions…great post~

    Reply

  589. Anonymous says

    I either strike out at Old Navy or find so many things to spruce up my wardrobe without costing a whole lot! Love it!

    Reply

  594. Anonymous says

    Love me some Old Navy and how cute would I look in some new clothes. Might even get the my teenage son a new t-shirt, if he plays nice and begs!!!

    Reply

  595. Anonymous says

    The flannel tops and tweed puffer vest is such a great combo! Lots of cute outfit inspirations. Thanks for doing homework at Old Navy. Great post!

    Reply

  597. Melissa D. says

    Just got our Old Navy shipment this week! I love that you are doing your Shopping with Sheaffer posts with their clothes! Keep it comin'!

    Reply

  604. A Lucky Peach says

    Loving the readers choice series. I bought the black tweed puffer vest. Can't wait for fall to wear it with a chambray shirt and boots.

    Reply

  605. Katie says

    Another Old Navy fan here! I shop there for myself and my kiddos! It was so much fun to see you in some things I tried on just last week! In fact, I bought the loafers as soon as I saw them and have told everyone who's commented on them that I was buying them to satisfy my crush on your mandarin moccassins from last year!

    Reply

  607. Annie Cox says

    Old Navy was always a hit or miss for me in the past but lately I've been loving their stuff. I also signed up for their credit card so it is easy to shop there when you have reward dollars to spend. What great things you found when you are there. I will have to check them out online. Thanks!

    Reply

  614. Anonymous says

    Love the post! I really want the brown vest but they don't have my size 🙁 Thinking about the pixie pants and the flannel shirts!

    Reply

  615. Tracey says

    This makes me want to go to Old Navy right now for some fall clothes. It is 90 degrees outside but I need flannel and a puffer ASAP!

    Reply

  622. Work it Mommy says

    Ive been a Gap Brand lover forEVER and always score great deals at Old Navy! I also have a brand credit card and feel extra spoiled when I get to shop for "free" when redeeming my rewards points 🙂 I looked forward to this post just see what goodies I need to buy next! Thanks Sheaffer and Old Navy, you guys never disappoint!
    Whitney

    Reply

  623. Jenna F says

    I already have many of those items you showcased which is so wonderful! I have been eying that plaid shirt forever and it's continually been out in my size… but I won't give up because I GOTTA HAVE IT… IT'S TOO CUTE! Thanks for the great post. 🙂

    Reply

  624. Jcouvutsakis says

    I really liked the flannel shirt! I find their sizes to be somewhat inconsistent and usually only order online for my kids. I do like their outerwear choices!

    Reply

  628. Danielle says

    So glad you did a post on Old Navy! I've been super impressed with them lately. They've really stepped up their styles and I love their workout line!

    Reply

  631. MC says

    Most of my wardrobe is from ON, and I have always been a big fan. I did find some good deals here in your post, so I am heading over to place an order now…it might be time for a flannel shirt for me!

    I have that tweed puffer in a wine color from last year and LOVE it!

    Reply

  632. Lyndsey Harms says

    Love this post! I was lucky enough to get the tweed vest last year and the cream puffer/quilt this year! Love that flannel, I need!

    Reply

  633. jillianwvu says

    I love the plaid shirt and I was just able to scoop up the tweed vest from an Old Navy store out of state. 🙂 SCORE! It is on its way to me now!! xo

    Reply

  651. Ralinn Jones says

    I just purchased online the orange suede moccasins, chiffon printed blouse and boys pj's. I was so excited I forgot to order the vest. I will have to place another order.

    Reply

  652. ZageZ says

    I'm digging the pixie pant. I bought the navy & black pair. Love how they hit at ankle and have some stretch to them.
    Going to go back and grab a couple flannel shirts for sure.

    Reply

  653. jayme707 says

    Love ON! Have the tweed vest in navy from last year… will def be getting some flannel shirts for the fall! So cute with the Hunter boots 🙂

    Reply

  660. Sharon Simmers says

    The pixie pants are adorable, but how would they look on a curvier figure? LOL! Love the post on Old Navy! Very affordable! How comfortable are the strappy booties? I teach, on my feet all day??

    Reply

  667. sloandefyinggravity says

    Good grief at all the comments! Just wanted to say about the sizing: I am usually a 0, but at ON, I can be an XXS all the way through M. Their sizing is sooo off. It's because of the way they cut their clothes. Price can't be beat, though!

    Reply

  671. Sarah E @ theteacherswife.com says

    I'm definitely a fan of Old Navy….they have great prices and some cute stuff! I love the plaid shirt!

    Reply

  676. Bobby says

    Old navy is definitely one of my favorites, price wise!! I didn't get to order anything today, because I recently bought myself a denim shirt! (someone told me it was a closet staple!!) 🙂

    Reply

  678. Paige says

    love the first outfit…the plaid flannel and vest…too bad it's sold out now! The red hunters pull it all together-so cute! I've always been a fan of old navy!

    Reply

  681. Heidi Wilkins says

    I have always loved Old Navy! They have the best selection of things that come in tall just like I need. Now that I just had a baby I love dressing my little guy in Old Navy clothes too

    Reply

  685. Michelle Stack says

    I love Old Navy! I didn't purchase anything tonight, but I was there last weekend and bought red pixie pants, a plaid scarf, three shirts, and some jewelry! 🙂

    Reply

  686. Jen V. says

    Big Old Navy fan here! I think I get at least one package from them per week in the mail! Before I even saw this post, I ordered the flannel popover in red and the distressed straight fit jeans earlier today! Yay-another package to look forward to!

    Reply

  699. Sallie says

    I love this post! May just be my favorite! I'm definitely an Old Navy fan! I bought the tweed vest back when you first shared it…I could not wait 😉 I just ordered some pixie pants and a few boyfriend cardigans I had my eye on in the store the other day (super soft, long and just wonderful)…thanks for the awesome post! Also, I found the link to your floral scarf – http://m.oldnavy.gap.com/product.html?dn=op121526002&dv=1&shopid=1&pdn=oc14675

    Reply

  700. Kellyann Rohr says

    Those pixie pants were seriously cute on you! Loved them, may need to try some myself. I also loved the boyfriend jeans – adorable on you!

    Reply

  731. The Reeder Family says

    I love Old Navy and their petite options. It's so hard to find cute clothes, especially pants, for those of us who are vertically challenged and ON has some great options. Thanks for highlighting such cute outfits!

    Reply

  739. Tricia C says

    I love old navy for active wear, so that's what I ordered. Plus I got the plaid scarf you tried on! Can't wait to get the package in the mail 🙂

    Reply

  740. Alexis L. says

    You've hit it out of the ballpark again. Shopping with Sheaffer is so much fun 🙂 I wish I would've known Pixie Pants were gonna be $25 because I bought some 3 weeks ago 🙁 Buuut it's ok, I can just buy even more now! I actually think they fit TTS. When I sized up in Pixie, they stretched out and then fit too loose after some time.

    Reply

  745. Lindsey Jackson says

    I work at Old Navy and I absolutely love working there. You are right it does not get enough credit. Old Navy is upping it's fashion and it is exciting to see people loving it! Thanks for the post!

    Reply

  757. Carrie Dotson says

    True story, was in the process of ordering a blue and white checked flannel, a puffer vest, and a few other tops when I saw your FB post about the tweed vest. Of course that went in my cart too!
    I received my order last week and just love it all!!

    Reply

  761. Julia Banach says

    I tend to have a love/hate relationship with Old Navy and this is definitely a love day!! I'll be buying some flannels and Puffy vests soon!!

    Reply

  769. Sara says

    I shopped at ON a lot for back-to-school this year. I have 4 kids so I love getting cute & on-trend without going over my budget. Thanks for the fun post!

    Reply

  770. Anonymous says

    I love your blog but as a just-graduated-college-looking-for-a-job gal I have a hard time justifying some of the more expensive items. I love Old Navy and LOVED seeing your take on it! I finally ordered a few things since this is MUCH more in my budget!!! Look forward to more Old Navy posts! You're the best Sheaffer!! Amanda C.

    Reply

  780. Sherita Grant says

    I've been an Old Navy fan for years, especially for tops, tees, and children's clothes. Now, I'm off to start stocking up on Fall necessities!

    Reply

  781. Lesley East says

    Absolutely ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ i need to make a trip to old navy as soon as I win a gift card!! Again #singlemomstruggles ??? but it's life!! I love your blog. Read it daily!!!! Thanks for taking the time to share all the cuteness!!! ❌⭕️❌⭕️

    Reply

  784. samazmn says

    I ordered the rockstar jeans and the boyfriend jeans! Some of my favorite tshirts are their vintage ones I have more then I care to say! I wear them almost daily in the winter!

    Reply

  787. Leslie Seror says

    I've been shopping at ON for years! As a mom, I love that I can order stuff online, try it on at home, and return whatever doesn't work to my local store. Such a plus!

    Reply

  793. Morgan Kirk says

    Oh my sweet lands those booties and that jacket! I love when old navy and gap do 30% off (or more) sales! I buy all the things when that happens. Especially pants. I just got that flannel shirt you are wearing with your wellies a few weeks ago and I LOVE it!

    Reply

  795. The Coffer Family says

    I am an Old Navy shopper, thanks for posting about some great finds! I subscribe to your posts so I didn't get it until this morning so I think I missed the sale, but that's okay, they will have another one soon.
    Karina

    Reply

  813. Erin Sparrow says

    I already shop there for cute inexpensive toddler clothes- now I know to look at stuff for me too! Thanks for the tips!!

    Reply

  817. Steph Evans says

    Great Post! I really love your happy, silly, creative personality and look forward to getting your posts in my inbox. Keep up the great work! xo

    Reply

  830. sharon a says

    I LOVE Old Navy and am SOOOO happy you are adding them to your store rotation! 🙂 Yippeeeee! I have their military jacket (3 colors – they also had navy last year) and the puffer vest (s), plaid flannel, booties, many of their jeans, tees, tanks, etc! Love them! Thanks for featuring them. 🙂

    Reply

  833. Heather says

    I love Old Navy! I usually get my seasonal trendy pieces there without spending a lot of money. I have been wearing the rock star jeans for awhile and really love them. Most of all their active wear is reasonably priced and so comfortable, the yoga pants are the best!

    Reply

  838. Donna Epperson says

    I LOVE Old Navy!!! It is a great place for find cute clothes for a great price. I usually mix and match their stuff with GAP or Jcrew. I have that leopard top as well, how soft is that?!? Thanks for a great post!

    Reply

  842. Amanda Ford says

    I usually only shop at old navy for my kids, but I am loving everything about this post! Will be getting some ON for myself!

    Reply

  849. whitneythompson says

    Love love love that there are affordable options available in Canada that don't cost an arm and a leg.. Free shipping too! Definitely getting the puffer vest and flannel combo

    Reply

  851. Meagan Smith says

    I just went into Old Navy last week and made a mental note of a few things I want (the green long cargo jacket and flannel included!). My Fall wardrobe needs some major TLC! Thanks for all the Fall inspiration. 🙂

    Reply

  852. Lesliejane says

    Single mom with a son in college & trying to keep my work wardrobe current! Old Navy fits this girl's budget. Especially loving all the booties and the zippered pants…good fit for a short & curvy girl!

    Reply

  856. Because Shanna Said So says

    852 comments????? Girl, you amaze me every single day!! And I have def been on an Old Navy kick lately! So many cute things….like those boyfriend skinny jeans. I have them and LOVE them! Thanks for the giveaway….fingers crossed and can snag one of the prizes! xoxo

    Reply

  861. Stefanie says

    I love Old Navy! Great clothes at great prices, especially for my 2.5 yo daughter!! Thanks for posting those Rockstar Skinny Zip Pocket Jeans!!! They are so cute, I will be buying them today!!

    Reply

  864. Ashley Stewart says

    I just bought the floral scarf you are sporting and also the red/black version of the half-button flannel. They have such great fall finds!

    Reply

  869. Leanne Connor says

    Thanks so much for the awesome giveaway! I haven't been able to get the pixie pants to work on me but I may have to try again because I love the printed pixies outfit with the solid blacktop and pop-of-color moccasins! I've already max'd out my shopping budget this month and I'm now mentally preparing for next month, two weeks to go! 😉

    Reply

  875. Anonymous says

    I have many of my bottoms from old navy and I just love them! I am so glad you decided to start featuring them on your blog 🙂

    Allison F.

    Reply

  878. Amy Kleis says

    I actually have several pairs of pixie pants. But, mine are either true to size or down for me?? I'm a huge ON shopper with the boys clothes, because they make their stuff just a bit bigger than the gap for kids clothes, but I have always liked their options and when I found out many years ago that they were sister stores with the Gap, I was totally in.

    I have that military jacket …they actually had that last fall and winter, as well as the camo, now I'm super excited that it did so good they are bringing it back!!

    Welcome back to ON! And if there is one thing from ON that I can tell you is a "MUST HAVE" it's their "TAMI TANK". O M G….they are wonderful, wonderful, wonderful. Great for everything! I promise!

    Reply

  879. Leah says

    I love mixing in pieces from ON for myself and it's my go to place for my kiddos! Love the jean jacket. It's my birthday if that gives me extra points 😉

    Reply

  881. Unknown says

    I'm so glad you did this post because now I know we are about the same size so the size references will actually be beneficial. Thank you!

    Reply

  898. Katlin Smith says

    Ahhhh I'm so bumed the mixed media jacket is sold out in my size but I'm loving the camo jacket!!!! I love Old Navy!

    Reply

  899. Katie Zeidler says

    You found some awesome stuff at Old Navy!! I hadn't shopped there in years either… but now that I am pregnant and trying to not spend a fortune on maternity clothes, Old Navy has become a new favorite! Thanks for sharing your great finds!

    Reply

  900. andrea lohman says

    I just received the same exact vest yesterday and I love it! It's too bad they are sold out. I hope they restock!

    Reply

  907. Olga says

    I love this post!! I just found you through Tab and Erika's blog! I love it. Thanks for sharing your fall faves. I'll be running to old navy to check out some of them.

    Reply

  911. Karen W says

    I just scored that tweed vest in a size small in store at 50% off. It was hanging on a return rack at the registers. Apparently ON marks down all online exclusive items by 50% when they have been returned in-store. I didn't have any luck with the pixie pants, but after spotting the vest, I didn't care!

    Reply

  915. Shannon Everett says

    I bought the green military jacket online a couple of weeks ago, just in time for our trip to London, where I've been wearing it for the past week. It's perfect! So glad you like it too! I used to shop at Old Navy often and then stopped for a couple years, but just got back into it in the past couple of weeks as well! So fun! Loved this post!

    Reply

  917. Allie says

    Love Love the Jacket! I have had more fun shopping Old Navy the past year–such fun, cute cheap clothes! Time to shop for fall!

    Reply

  918. ecreal says

    I love your blog!! Thanks for inspiring me to walk out the door looking cute instead of my usual "mom uniform" of yoga pants and a t-shirt! I bought the flannel and the green military jacket, love them!

    Reply

  920. Lindsay says

    This was such a fun post! I seldom shop at Old Navy, but I'm looking to make some budget changes to my clothing allowance (i.e. I need to cut down my spending) so this is a great option. Everything looks so adorable on you no matter where you shop!!!

    Reply

  922. Emily Ann says

    I ordered… way too much! 3 dresses, 1 shirt, and some pixie pants to try! 🙂 I may or may not have an old navy addiction… Would love a gift card!!

    Reply

  927. Allison Laughlin says

    Sheaffer- I think this is my favorite blog post to date!!! Seriously, I have recently re-connected with Old Navy too:), after not shopping there for years. I'm not sure why I didn't shop there…I guess I didn't care for it but I think their styles are so great recently, esp this past summer. I hope to see more Old Navy posts in the future! Thank you for your fabulous blog!

    Reply

  934. Allison says

    love old navy! I just ordered a chambray shirt and red ballet flats from them the day before I saw this post 🙂 Now I think I need to go back and place another order, after seeing all the cute things you featured!

    Reply

  936. {Hi Sugarplum!} says

    Ok this is too weird!!! so you know that text I just sent you about keeping something sold out??? I was talking about this denim jacket! I got mine in the mail yesterday and fell in love!! Then I hop over to see what you've been up to…and you're looking too cute in the jacket! So no wonder it's sold out!!??!!!

    Reply

  938. Unknown says

    Love Old Navy!! I'm 20 weeks pregnant and keep finding so many cute things to order online. Thanks for the Old Navy post!!

    Reply

  940. Megan O. Burchett says

    I love Old Navy and your Target posts… much closer to my budget. In fact I bought a denim shirt from Target today. I was seriously considering the must-have-shirt look-a-like until I read the reviews. :/ Oh well…. 🙂

    Reply

  951. StacyHudson says

    Cute Cute Cute! I have a pair of the pixie pants and I do love them! I would say that most will probably want to size up. I'm really hoping the tweed vest gets restocked! These stores must just LOVE what PTMT does to their sales numbers!

    Reply

  952. DeborahRobson says

    I am usually not a huge fan of old navy's adult clothing but I am excited to check out the flannels and puffers!!

    Reply